Jim Souhan: Dear Brett Favre, I was wrong about you

  • Article by: JIM SOUHAN , Star Tribune
  • Updated: September 26, 2007 - 12:45 AM

There have been times the past three years when a lesser player would have and seemingly should have quit. And that was my recommendation.

Your Packers were rebuilding and logic dictated that they groom a replacement, perhaps former first-round pick Aaron Rodgers, who should at least theoretically be the quarterback of the future.

This logic, though, violated an aphorism that should be inscribed in every Hat O' Cheddar: Don't rush the great ones out the door, because you might never see their kind again.

Remember when the Orioles moved Cal Ripken from short to third to make way for their hot young shortstop prospect? Remember the guy's name? You shouldn't. Ripken moved in favor of the immortal Manny Alexander. (Think Jason Bartlett, without his bat, glove and hustle.)

Remember who replaced Troy Aikman? Quincy Carter. Fran Tarkenton? Tommy Kramer. Dan Marino? Jay Fiedler. John Elway? Bubby Brister.

In 2005, your Packers finished 4-12. Samkon Gado was your top rusher. You guys finished 22nd in the NFL in points scored. Brett, you threw for 20 touchdowns and an incredible 29 interceptions. It was obviously time to retire.

You stuck around, though, and new coach Mike McCarthy set about improving your "efficiency." That was the coach's way of saying he didn't want to see his Hall of Fame quarterback making desperate, stupid plays.

Through 12 games last year, your Packers were 4-8. You had just lost 35-0 to the Patriots, 34-24 to the Seahawks and 38-10 to the Jets. In those three games, Brett, you threw two touchdown passes and five interceptions.

Obviously, you were done. I thought it was time to stick a utensil -- in deference to the cheeseheads, make it a fondue fork -- into the toughest, most daring and most error-prone great quarterback in league history.

And I was as wrongheaded as the phrase "Gopher Rose Bowl."

Your Packers have now won seven in a row. Sunday, in a victory over San Diego, you led your 38th fourth-quarter comeback victory, reached 150 victories as a starting quarterback and threw your 420th touchdown pass, tying Marino atop the all-time list.

This Sunday, you will make your 241st consecutive start, the most ever by a quarterback, and you will pass former Vikings center Mick Tingelhoff for second on the all-time list at all positions.

If you had retired when there seemed little hope for the Packers, little hope to end your career gallantly, we would have missed out on one of the most riveting players in league history setting records and keeping the quaintest franchise in the NFL relevant.

We would have missed out on you bringing all that drama and history to the Metrodome on Sunday, in the one game on the Vikings' schedule that matters regardless of record.

As records fall, your reputation rises, Brett, if that's possible. NFL analysts suddenly are listing you among the top five quarterbacks in NFL history.

What is more relevant this week is this: Nearing your 38th birthday, two years after almost playing yourself out of the league, you are once again the best quarterback in the division, once again the best reason to watch the NFL in the heartland.

Sincerely, Jim Souhan

Jim Souhan can be heard Sundays from 10 a.m.-noon on AM-1500 KSTP. jsouhan@startribune.com

  • related content

  • Ferguson's road back long, painful

    Tuesday September 25, 2007

    While with the Packers, the receiver suffered the dreaded Lisfranc injury. On Sunday, Green Bay will get to gauge his progress.

  • Vikings offense stuck in low gear

    Tuesday September 25, 2007

    The Vikings spent much of the offseason retooling key parts of their offense.Tarvaris Jackson was made the starting quarterback; running...

  • Reports : Bears to bench Grossman, start Griese

    Tuesday September 25, 2007

    Rex Grossman reportedly will be benched by the Chicago Bears for Sunday's game at Detroit, with Brian Griese starting at...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Portland 0 Postponed
Brooklyn 0
Sacramento 0 Postponed
New York 0
Philadelphia 74 FINAL
New Orleans 99
Minnesota 84 FINAL
Oklahoma City 92
Orlando 94 FINAL
Memphis 103
Boston 99 FINAL
Utah 90
Denver 98 FINAL
LA Clippers 102
Army 68 FINAL
American Univ 66
Wright State 64 FINAL
Detroit 53
Syracuse 83 FINAL
North Carolina 93
Cleveland State 56 FINAL
Oakland 59
Delaware State 54 FINAL
NC Central 55
High Point 63 FINAL
Presbyterian 54
Howard 45 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 42
Coppin State 84 FINAL
NC A&T 71
Nicholls 51 FINAL
Northwestern St 80
Hampton 56 FINAL
SC State 65
Gardner-Webb 59 FINAL
Campbell 78
MD-Eastern Shore 72 FINAL
Florida A&M 65
Stephen F Austin 82 FINAL
Lamar 65
Central Arkansas 67 FINAL
New Orleans 87
Norfolk State 70 FINAL
Savannah State 54
SE Louisiana 61
Sam Houston St 80 FINAL
Abilene Christian 63
McNeese State 84 FINAL
Incarnate Word 86
Milwaukee 48 FINAL
Valparaiso 73
Alcorn State 66 FINAL
Alabama A&M 78
Southern U 59 FINAL
Alabama State 63
Prairie View 68 FINAL
Ark-Pine Bluff 105
Texas 86 FINAL
Iowa State 89
Texas Southern 85 FINAL
Miss Valley St 84
Long Island 85 FINAL
Bryant 88
Central Conn St 51 FINAL
St Francis-NY 49
Fairleigh Dickinson 0 Postponed
Sacred Heart 0
St Francis-PA 87 FINAL
Wagner 74
Delaware State 59 FINAL
NC Central 66
Howard 53 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 61
Coppin State 49 FINAL
NC A&T 67
Hampton 88 FINAL
SC State 53
Norfolk State 54 FINAL
Savannah State 56
MD-Eastern Shore 54 FINAL
Florida A&M 64
Angelo State 55 FINAL
Abilene Christian 70
Samford 32 FINAL
(25) Chattanooga 49
Prairie View 83 FINAL
Ark-Pine Bluff 66
Alcorn State 58 FINAL
Alabama A&M 55
Southern U 53 FINAL
Alabama State 49
Texas Southern 63 FINAL
Miss Valley St 52
(12) Texas A&M 61 FINAL
(1) South Carolina 79
Robert Morris 68 FINAL
Mount St Marys 44
East Tenn St 72 FINAL
Mercer 70
Wofford 56 FINAL
Furman 58
Morehead St 64 FINAL
Tenn Tech 54
Illinois 57 FINAL
Michigan 70
Quinnipiac 0 Postponed
Manhattan 0
Saint Peters 0 Postponed
Rider 0
(18) Miss State 59 FINAL
Auburn 48
(15) Nebraska 72 FINAL
(20) Iowa 78


question of the day

Poll: How optimistic are you about the 2015 Twins?

Weekly Question





Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters