This week's meeting of the Minneapolis Heritage Preservation Commission was unusually lively.
On the agenda was a proposal by Alatus LLC to build a 40-story condo tower in the St. Anthony Falls Historic District, which limits the height and scale of development in the area. And the commission needed to make two decisions: whether to allow demolition of a funeral home and whether to permit construction of the tower.
In a packed room, 13 people spoke out against the project and 10 spoke in favor of it. Most in favor praised its design and said that it would bring welcome density to the neighborhood. Some, including people already living in the neighborhood, said the area needed a better selection of housing options.
One couple who sold their suburban house two years ago said they had fallen in love with the riverfront (after an interlude in Uptown they called a "disaster") and were living in an apartment along the river but wanted to buy in the Alatus building.
Those opposed were passionate in their conviction. Several said that while the tower was attractive, it's being proposed for the wrong site and would be better-suited downtown. "It belongs on the other side of the river," said one.
Some, like the HPC commissioners themselves, focused on the precedent that would be set by ignoring the guidelines established in the St. Anthony Falls Historic District.
"These guidelines are the only thing that stand between us and oblivion," one neighbor said.
After two deadlocked votes on whether to allow demolition of the funeral home, a third vote in favor of allowing demolition passed after Commissioner Constance Vork included a requirement that for six months the developer should use media and other means of finding someone willing to move and reuse the building.
After a brief discussion, and a separate motion, the request for a certificate of appropriateness to build the tower was denied 6-2.
Commissioner Ginny Lackovic summarized the general sentiment of those opposed: "The height alone is hard to get past … it has too much of an impact on the character of the district. We have to go with the guidelines."
The HPC's decision can be appealed by the developer to the City Council. After the meeting, Alatus principal Bob Lux said that he is considering his options.