ADVERTISEMENT

Those pesky wackos are back again ... Finally time to do the right thing?

  • Blog Post by: Bill Gleason
  • December 15, 2013 - 11:51 AM

In a seemingly endless stream, pesky wackos roll off the line at a bottling plant ... 

Source: Flickr

[The University of Minnesota's]  senior director of communications sent out an internal message that read in part, "I looked her up [Dr. Judy Stone] and can't tell if she's a wacko or not…. I get nervous about anyone who would pay any attention to Carl."  [link]

"Carl" is Dr. Carl Elliott, Pathetic. 

Wacko - anyone who does not agree with the University of Minnesota administration's official position

University of Minnesota Communications Handbook 

Background

Earlier posts on the Markingson case have appeared on the Community Voices site:

Send in the wackos ...

and

Markingson Case: Has the Gordian Knot puzzle
been solved at the University of Minnesota?

 

Recent Developments

Although the Faculty Senate at the University of Minnesota voted overwhelmingly for an outside, independent, investigation of the Markingson case, it appears that an attempt to ignore what went wrong in the case is in progress.

President Kaler said in a recent interview with the Minnesota Daily:

I’m a big believer in shared governance, and so I’m willing to take the advice of the Senate and the panel. ... I think they will find that our review processes are robust and that we do, in fact, protect patients in clinical trials, but there’s been concern raised in how we do that, and so our goal is to air out clearly and very publicly what we do and have a panel of external experts validate that and be sure we are doing this absolutely as well as can be done.

It’s certainly resulted as a consequence of a lot of repetitive publicity about the Markingson case, but it’s not a review of the Markingson case; it’s a review of what we are doing now and what we’re going to do moving forward.

"it's not a review of the Markingson case"

"It's certainly resulted as a consequence of a lot of repetitive publicity about the Markingson case, but it's not a review of the Markingson case."

These remarks seem more than a little defensive. And the direction in which they lead do not seem much different from the one we've seen out of the University of Minnesota administration since the inception of the Markingson case. 

Letter

And so it should be no surprise that these wackos who have been generating a lot of repetitive publicity about the Markingson case are back whining and writing more letters, this one requesting that a promised outside investigation be done right.

The nerve of these wackos ...

Lemmens Follow Up Letter Senate Dec 11 2013 by MarkingsonCase

Time to do the right thing? 

 Da Mayor: "Doctor, always do the right thing."

(link)

The time is always right to do the right thing.   Martin Luther King

 
Do the right thing, even when it is hard.  Joel Osteeen


Do the right thing because it is right. W. Clement Stone

 
Sometimes it is better to lose, and do the right thing... Tony Blair

Leaders are people who do the right thing. Warren Bennis

 
In plain Texas talk: It's do the right thing. Ross Perot

 
You do the right thing, even if it makes you feel bad. The purpose of life is not to be happy but to be worthy of happiness. Tracy Kidder

 Or, as Mark Yudof said in his inaugural address as president of the University of Minnesota:

"Simply stated, it is imperative that we continue to embrace our land-grant roots if we are to thrive."

"The need for integrity permeates every aspect of the University. The education mission of the University must be taken seriously--not just the way to get state funding."

"Administrators should tell the truth, keep their word, implement what they promise, and not dissemble. My point is plain enough: Without integrity, the phrase higher education is an oxymoron."

"When making decisions, I view shared governance and consultation with constituent groups as only fair because of the enormous stake they have in the University. Without fairness there is no legitimacy and no buy in to the institutional vision." 

 

Mark Yudof handled a horrible scandal in the athletic department with grace and dignity,  with no excuses and no dissembling. I have been very disappointed with the University of Minnesota administration since his presidency. Yudof fired people (the athletic director as well as coaches and support staff) and had Tonya Moten Brown essentially take over the athletic department. And his humility was not false.

The time for stonewalling has passed. Trying to dodge the issues inherent in the Markingson case is a fool's game. A university without integrity is not really a university. Bread and circuses do not a great university make, nor idle chatter about the infamous third greatest public research university in the world.

Time to walk the talk, President Kaler.  Otherwise,  disappointed  University of Minnesota alums will have to take a hike from their alma mater.  In the Twin Cities alone there are plenty of places for higher education philanthropy besides the University of Minnesota - Augsburg and Macalester colleges being two examples. Note that at these two schools the student debt at graduation is lower than that at the public University of Minnesota, to our everlasting disgrace.  I hope not.

One might whine that Mac is a school for the rich, a terrible and untrue argument, but such a charge ridiculous on its face for Augsburg College with its much more modest endowment. When Auggie, as it is familiarly known,  got donor money of questionable provenance, they gave it back. This is what doing the right thing means.  And the education available at Auggie is hardly for chumps. An Auggie, Peter Agre, recently won a Nobel Prize in chemistry. Nice ROI on that, I'd say. Kudos, Auggie, a Minnesota school that makes me proud. Macalester is also in this category as well as many other fine Minnesota  small liberal arts colleges, or SLACs to use au courant higher ed jargon.

Our recent University of Minnesota debt-saddled alums and their parents are none too happy with the performance of our university. Nor are our state legislators who are heartsick and bewildered by the fact that we are one of the leaders in the country - for student debt. Perhaps the plan is to salvage our position with sports dollars? I understand that Louie Nanne has been charged with raising two hundred million dollars for our athletics program. Under the present circumstances of crushing debt for our students, this is pathetic.

And of course if one desires to contribute money for medical research, there is always the Mayo. What's been going on at Fairview-University hospital lately does not exactly inspire warm and fuzzy feelings in the hearts of the populace. People will vote on the University's performance with their feet and their checkbooks. This goes also for the people in the state legislature.

If the University wants to see private philanthropic support, perhaps they should give us something to be proud of? Manufactured hash tags like #umnproud will not suffice.

Is it finally time to do the right thing in the Markingson matter?

More evasion will only serve to further erode our reputation in the real world. Out there where recent University of Minnesota administrations apparently would prefer not to go.

© 2014 Star Tribune