Ask Amy: Family wants baby to visit but mom's banned

  • Article by: AMY DICKINSON
  • December 13, 2013 - 1:29 PM

Dear Amy: My boyfriend and I live together. He is 30 and I am 26. We are raising our 10-month-old son together. I had a falling out several months ago with his parents, and now I am not allowed to go to their house.

My boyfriend wants to bring our baby to their house, but I don’t want him to take the child there because they have banned me.

His mother gets really upset if we don’t spend the entire day with them on a Saturday/Sunday and holidays. Our final blowup happened on a day when we arrived at 3 p.m. and were yelled at for being late. I defended us by explaining we had spent the first part of the day with my family, who live five hours away. She kept making comments about how late we were and my boyfriend decided we should leave. I have been banned from going there again because I “talked back.”

I understand that my boyfriend is torn and wants to see his family, but I don’t think it’s fair that I have to stay behind. Because I can’t go there, our son isn’t going either. His dad asks my boyfriend every week when he is bringing the baby; this puts pressure on me, every weekend and holiday.

I have offered to apologize to them, but he thinks it will fall on deaf ears. He has four brothers and sisters and we have invited them to come to our place so they can see each other, but they won’t come out of loyalty to their mother.

Can you help us resolve this situation?

Amy says: From your description of this woman, I would think you would be relieved to be banned from her home. However, I understand that there is a principle at stake, and I agree that banning one member of a family unit because of a disagreement is intolerable.

You could attempt to make peace. Contact her to say, “I’m sorry about this rift. Can we work things out?” Your guy will also have to be very firm with his parents and say, “How would you feel if I banned one of you from my home? I am part of my own family now, and if you want to see one member of the family, you will have to be willing to see all of us (at least some of the time).” Until he can do this, you can expect this uneasy imbalance to continue.

Send questions via e-mail to Amy Dickinson at

© 2018 Star Tribune