Hax: Family discussions are always weighty
- Article by: CAROLYN HAX
- December 10, 2013 - 3:40 PM
Dear Carolyn: Every member of my immediate family views thinness as the absolute key measure of success in life. Some are bulimic, some anorexic, but all have eating disorders.
I’m in my mid-50s, athletic, and of average weight according to medical guidelines. My weight has fluctuated about 15 pounds through the years. I visit as frequently as I can from a several-state distance.
The very first thing, said to me upon arrival is: “You look like you’ve lost weight.” Or, if I’m up 15, nothing is said but diet tips will be given throughout the visit.
My parents are elderly, and it’s too late to change that pattern now. My sister, though, is an unwanted, talking scale. Many years ago, while I was getting rid of post-baby fat, she grabbed my niece and my daughter and went into a circle dance, chanting, “We’re the skinnies! We’re the skinnies!” Round and around they went. I hated her for it, and I hated me for being “fat.”
Recently, in the middle of a conversation about what to do about ailing parents, she chimes in, out of the blue, with, “You’re doing so well with your weight! I’m so proud of you. We’ve all been talking about it.” She’s ruthless.
I was thinking, “$+&! you.” But just said nothing. I never want to hear a word from her again on the topic. What to say to stop it, once and for all?
Carolyn says: My (imagined) hat’s off to you for still visiting often. My car might have forgotten how to get there after years of cruel, humanity-negating myopia like this.
Assuming you keep up the visits, I offer three words: “I don’t recall.” As in:
“I don’t recall asking your opinion of my weight.”
“I don’t recall asking for help with my diet.”
“I don’t recall seeking your approval.”
“I don’t recall any part of our parents’ care that involves my weight.”
“I don’t recall any mention of weight in discussions of morality or values.”
“I don’t recall ever agreeing that weight is a measure of a person’s character.”
“I don’t recall when discussing weight was ever helpful to me.”
“I don’t recall ever judging your worth based on your appearance.”
And, “Your sick values aren’t welcome around my daughter.”
Each and every time, speak with minimal emotion, and follow each and every time by disengaging — changing the subject, leaving the room, getting up to “stretch my legs,” maybe with a two-handed slap to the belly — or a decision to stay gone for good.
I pity your sister and parents for how many of their life chips they’ve put on this meaningless square. With resolve and some practice (in therapy, if the “I hated me” still applies), you too can react to their comments more with pity than outrage. I expect that will help.
Bait and switch
Dear Carolyn: When a woman asks what I think of her new tattoo, how do I respond? Look without looking? Especially when I’m “being a pervert” for looking at her chest. Even if that’s where it is.
Carolyn says: It’s just bait, which is generally best not taken (because it gets you involved with baiters). When in doubt: “I think there’s no answer that doesn’t get me in trouble.”
E-mail Carolyn Hax at firstname.lastname@example.org, or chat with her at 11 a.m. Friday at www.washingtonpost.com.
© 2014 Star Tribune