Therapy for insomnia can double odds of recovery from depression
- Article by: BENEDICT CAREY
- New York Times
- November 23, 2013 - 6:07 PM
Doctors have been looking to improve the effectiveness of depression treatment for decades, and this weekend they got a break from an unexpected quarter: behavioral sleep medicine. Psychologists reported Saturday that a particular short-term therapy for insomnia could double the likelihood that people recover from the mood disorder — putting a spotlight on a little-known approach to poor sleep.
“I think it’s increasingly likely that this kind of sleep therapy will be used as a possible complement to standard care,” said Dr. John M. Oldham, chief of staff at the Menninger Clinic in Houston. “We are the court of last resort for the most difficult-to-treat patients, and I think sleep problems have been extremely under-recognized as a critical factor.”
For the time being, experts say, the treatment, known as cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, or CBT-I, is not widely available. Most insurers cover it, and the rates for private practitioners are roughly the same as for any psychotherapy, ranging from $100 to $250 an hour, depending on the therapist. But the American Board of Sleep Medicine has certified just 400 practitioners of behavioral treatment, mostly psychologists, in the United States — they are sparse, even in big cities.
And the need is great. Depression is the most common mood disorder, affecting some 18 million American adults in any given year. Most also have insomnia, and four studies of CBT-I for depression, in combination with medication, are nearing completion.
“There aren’t many of us doing this therapy,” said Shelby Harris, the director of the behavioral sleep medicine program at Montefiore Medical Center in New York, who also has a private practice in Tarrytown, N.Y. “I feel like we all know each other.”
That may change soon. According to preliminary results, one of the four studies has found that when CBT-I cures insomnia — it does so 40 percent to 50 percent of the time, previous work suggests — it powerfully complements the effect of antidepressant drugs. In the past year, the American Psychological Association has recognized sleep psychology as a specialty, and the Department of Veterans Affairs has begun a program to train about 600 sleep specialists, said Michael T. Smith, a professor at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine and president of the Society of Behavioral Sleep Medicine.
Insomnia disorder is defined as at least three months of poor sleep that causes problems at work, at home or in relationships.
“There’s been a huge recognition that insomnia especially cuts across a wide variety of medical disorders, and there’s a need to address it,” Smith said.
The therapy is easy to teach, said Colleen Carney, director of the sleep and depression lab at Ryerson University in Toronto, whose presentation at a conference Saturday raised hopes for depression treatment. “In the study we did, I trained students to administer the therapy,” she said in an interview, “and the patients in the study got just four sessions.”
CBT-I is not a single technique but a collection of complementary ideas. Some date to the 1970s; others are more recent. One is called stimulus control, which involves breaking the association between being in bed and activities like watching television or eating. Another is sleep restriction: setting a regular “sleep window” and working to stick to it. The therapist typically has patients track their efforts on a standardized form called a sleep diary. Patients record bedtimes and when they wake up each day, as well as their perceptions about quality of sleep and number of awakenings. To this the therapist might add common-sense advice such as reducing caffeine and alcohol intake, and making sure the bedroom is dark and quiet.
Those three elements — stimulus control, restriction and common sense — can do the trick for many patients. For those who need more, the therapist applies cognitive therapy — a means of challenging self-defeating assumptions. Patients fill out a standard questionnaire that asks how strongly they agree with statements such as: “Without an adequate night’s sleep, I can hardly function the next day”; “I believe insomnia is the result of a chemical imbalance”; and “Medication is probably the only solution to sleeplessness.” In sessions, people learn to challenge those beliefs, using evidence drawn from their own experiences.
In short-term studies of a month or two, CBT-I has been about as effective as prescription sleeping pills. But it appears to have more staying power.
© 2014 Star Tribune