ADVERTISEMENT

House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) walks to the House floor for a vote after the Senate voted to end the government shutdown and raise the debt limit at the Capitol in Washington, Oct. 16, 2013. President Barack Obama swiftly signed a bill funding the government through Jan. 15 and raising the debt limit through Feb. 7. on Wednesday after Senate talks produced a deal amounting to a near total defeat for conservatives.

Doug Mills, Nyt - Nyt

Shutdown sets off  family feud within a badly splintered GOP

  • Article by: JONATHAN MARTIN, JIM RUTENBERG and JEREMY W. PETERS
  • New York Times
  • October 19, 2013 - 7:31 PM

 

After the budget standoff ended in crushing defeat last week and the political damage reports began to pile up for Republicans, one longtime party leader after another stepped forward to chastise their less seasoned, Tea Party-inspired colleagues who drove the losing strategy.

“Let’s face it: It was not a good maneuver,’ ” Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah, the senior Senate Republican and supporter of the deal that ended the showdown, said in an interview in the Capitol on Thursday. “And that’s when you’ve got to have the adults running the thing.”

Around the same time, roughly a thousand miles away in Mississippi, a 42-year-old Republican state senator, Chris McDaniel, was announcing his bid to take the seat of one of those “adults,” Sen. Thad Cochran, 75, a six-term incumbent and the very picture of the Republican Old Guard whose vote to end the standoff McDaniel called “more of a surrender than a compromise.”

Insurgent conservative groups like the Senate Conservatives Fund, the Madison Project and Club for Growth immediately announced their support for McDaniel, chairman of the Mississippi state Senate’s Conservative Caucus and a former Christian-radio host, providing an early glimpse into what the next three years are likely to hold for the Republican Party.

The budget fight that led to the first government shutdown in 17 years did not just set off a round of recriminations among Republicans over who was to blame for the politically disastrous standoff. It also heralded a very public escalation of a far more consequential battle for control of the Republican Party, a confrontation between Tea Party conservatives — led by Texas Sen. Ted Cruz — and establishment Republicans that will play out in the coming congressional and presidential primaries in 2014 and 2016 — and one that has been simmering since President George W. Bush’s administration, if not before.

In dozens of interviews, elected officials, strategists and donors from both wings of the party were blunt in drawing the intraparty battle lines, suggesting that the time for an open feud over the Republican future has arrived.

“It’s civil war in the GOP,” declared Richard Viguerie, the veteran conservative warrior who helped invent the political direct mail business.

The moment draws comparisons to some of the biggest fights of recent Republican Party history — the 1976 clash between the insurgent faction of activists who supported Ronald Reagan for president that year and the moderate party leaders who stuck by President Gerald R. Ford, or the split between the conservative Goldwater and moderate Rockefeller factions in 1964.

Some Republicans note that both of those campaigns planted the seeds for the conservative movement’s greatest success: Reagan’s 1980 election and his two terms as president.

“The business community thought the supply-siders were nuts, and the country club Republicans thought the social conservatives scary,” William Kristol, editor of the Weekly Standard, said of those earlier squabbles.

Far from being chastened by the failure to achieve any of the concessions from President Obama they had sought, the conservative grass-roots activists who helped drive the confrontation in Congress and helped fuel support for the 144 House Republicans who voted against ending it are now ratcheting up their effort to rid the party of the sort of timorous Republicans who, they said, doomed their effort to defund the health law from the start.

“This was an inflection point, because the gap between what people believe in their hearts and what they see in Washington is getting wider and wider,” said Jim DeMint, the former South Carolina senator and Heritage Foundation president, who, as a founder of the Senate Conservatives Fund, is a sort of political godfather to the junior Republican congressmen who engineered the health care fight and shutdown.

But the party’s establishment leaders feel the activist wing’s tactics did not work. “Successful movements inside parties are movements that persuade people,” said GOP strategist Karl Rove. “The question is, can they persuade? And thus far the jury’s out.”

© 2014 Star Tribune