Player, Team 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th Points David Price, Rays 14 13 1 153 Justin Verlander, Tigers 13 13 2 149 Jered Weaver, Angels 2 14 9 2 70 Felix Hernandez, Mariners 5 10 6 41 Fernando Rodney, Rays 1 5 4 8 38 Chris Sale, White Sox 1 4 6 17 Jim Johnson, Orioles 1 3 5 Matt Harrison, Rangers 2 2 Yu Darvish, Rangers 1 1 Below is a breakdown of the 28 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each team in the American League. Name Affiliation Chapter 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th Mel Antonen SI.com BAL Price Verlander Rodney Weaver Johnson Bill Ballou Worcester (MA) Telegram & Gazette BOS Price Verlander Weaver Hernandez Harrison Daniel Barbarisi Wall Street Journal NY Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Sale Rob Bradford WEEI.com BOS Verlander Price Hernandez Weaver Rodney Joe Christensen Minneapolis Star Tribune MIN Verlander Price Rodney Hernandez Weaver Shi Davidi At Large TOR Price Verlander Rodney Weaver Hernandez Drew Davison Fort Worth Star Telegram TEX Rodney Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Martin Fennelly Tampa Tribune TB Price Verlander Rodney Weaver Johnson Ken Fidlin Toronto Sun TOR Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Rodney Gerry Fraley Dallas Morning News TEX Price Verlander Weaver Rodney Johnson Ben Goessling St. Paul Pioneer Press MIN Verlander Price Hernandez Sale Darvish Scot Gregor Arlington Heights (IL) Daily Herald CHI Price Verlander Weaver Sale Rodney Lynn Henning Detroit News DET Verlander Price Weaver Rodney Sale John Hickey At Large SEA Price Verlander Weaver Johnson Hernandez Jim Ingraham News Herald CLE Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Sale Bruce Jenkins San Francisco Chronicle OAK Verlander Price Weaver Sale Hernandez Chad Jennings Journal News NY Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Sale Dennis Manoloff Cleveland Plain Dealer CLE Price Verlander Sale Weaver Harrison Michael Martinez FoxSportsWest.com LA Price Weaver Verlander Rodney Hernandez Sam Mellinger Kansas City Star KC Verlander Price Hernandez Weaver Rodney Jon Paul Morosi Fox Sports.com DET Price Verlander Hernandez Weaver Rodney Jorge Ortiz USA Today OAK Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Rodney Bill Plunkett Orange County Register LA Price Weaver Verlander Rodney Sale Joe Posnanski SI.com KC Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Sale Ken Rosenthal Fox Sports.com BAL Price Verlander Weaver Hernandez Rodney Joe Smith Tampa Bay Times TB Price Verlander Rodney Weaver Hernandez Larry Stone Seattle Times SEA Verlander Price Weaver Hernandez Rodney Dave Van Dyke Chicago Tribune CHI Price Verlander Hernandez Sale Weaver