Amy: Mom, 70, and beau are having fun, but...

  • Article by: AMY DICKINSON
  • September 19, 2012 - 2:27 PM

Dear Amy: My 70-year-old mother divorced my father five years ago after 30 years of a constantly emotionally abusive marriage. She slowly recovered her sense of self, made friends and had a fairly fulfilling (if quiet) life. She met a married man three years ago. They got together at their 50th high school reunion. He lives in the South and she lives in New England, and neither wants to move. They speak every day on the phone and travel together. They are having a great time.

He is retired and very well-off. He pays for her trips and plane tickets. I am thrilled for my mother, but my problem is that although he has been separated for many years and is living apart, this man is still legally married to his wife.

This does not bother my mother. She has no plans to remarry. He wants to stay legally married because of "severe financial ramifications" with investments he and his wife have together.

I am not buying his excuses. I feel my mother is being taken advantage of. I feel he could easily get divorced. I think she is living a fantasy and may get hurt should this man decide to return to his wife or find another girlfriend. Most of the family agrees with me, but Mom is adamant that it doesn't bother her and she just wants to enjoy whatever time they have together. Your thoughts?

Amy says: Your mother cannot catch a break. She is finally liberated from her abusive marriage, and now her children decide to micromanage her romantic life. This man is being honest with her, she is fine with things as they are, and she is having a great time. I can't figure out how this adds up to him taking advantage of her.

Your mother could, in fact, get hurt. At 70 years old, given what she has been through, don't you imagine that she already knows that? If your mother's values dictated that she wouldn't see this man unless he got legally divorced, it would be up to her (not you) to convey that.

Sharing bounty

Dear Amy: I recently came into some money but have not changed my lifestyle much because I'm trying to keep things as normal as possible for my kids. I have increased my charitable giving.

My question is about giving money to friends. I have wonderful friends and none of them would ever expect this kind of gift.

I see many of them struggling financially, and I would love to give some of them a one-time gift, but I'm worried about our relationships changing and becoming uncomfortable -- or ruined. I helped a relative who asked, and it turned very tense when he kept asking for more.

Is there a way to do this smoothly, or is it just destined to be awkward and maybe shouldn't be done at all?

Amy says: I have had relationships bolstered by loans, gifts and general bounty-sharing. But you can't do this if you have specific expectations about how things will go for you.

Giving money can create a dependence and expectation for more, but if you enter the exchange carefully and with an open attitude, it can go well. You also need to marshal the power of a neutral "no."

You must also learn, however, how to tolerate hearing about other people's challenges without feeling compelled to fix them.

Was Amy rude?

Dear Amy: I was so disappointed in your response to the woman who said she was "horrified" when two women (neither was the bride) wore white to a wedding. I thought your response to her was rude. Everybody knows you are not supposed to wear white to a wedding. She was right to be shocked!

Amy says: I was responding to the rude and unkind tone of her letter. The biggest breach of etiquette was hers.

Send questions via e-mail to Amy Dickinson at or by mail to Ask Amy, Chicago Tribune, TT500, 435 N. Michigan Av., Chicago, IL 60611.

© 2018 Star Tribune