People joined hands Monday at a memorial across from the Century 16 theater in Aurora, Colo., where 12 people were killed and 58 wounded on July 20. What to do with the massacre site is a question that has troubled other people in places where gunmen have struck.

Alex Brandon, Associated Press

Raze or reopen Colorado theater?

  • Los Angeles Times
  • July 30, 2012 - 9:59 PM

AURORA, COLO. -- As a shattered community mourns its dead and struggles to move on, a thorny question faces the people of Aurora: What should be done with the site of one of the worst mass shootings in the nation's history?

For some, the pain is too raw, and they want the Century 16 movie theater razed. Others say that would be a victory for the shooter who opened fire at a packed screening.

There is no easy answer. When mass killings occur in public spaces -- Columbine High School, Virginia Tech, Tucson -- communities must balance honoring the dead with the business of getting on with life.

A makeshift memorial has taken shape on a dusty lot within sight of the theater, which is still cordoned off with crime scene tape. The growing piles of offerings -- flowers, candles, teddy bears, Bibles -- reach nearly halfway up 12 white crosses hammered into the dirt.

JoEllen Stotts, who visited the site with her granddaughter, suggested the theater be torn down and a park be built with a memorial wall honoring those who were there that night, living and dead, and those who came to their aid. "This is something that can't just disappear and go into the shadows," she said.

Many here say they can't imagine stepping inside the building again. Taylor Holzman, Stotts' granddaughter, used to see movies there a couple of times a week. "I can't even look at it now, let alone go sit in there," she said.

Others would like the theater to reopen. "I think John would want that," said Karen Lavin, whose nephew, 27-year-old John Larimer, was among the 12 killed on July 20. "He was a huge movie buff. ... Maybe a small memorial outside the theater with the names of the victims would be nice."

Some locals, noting the Century 16 is a popular gathering spot and source of needed jobs, envision reopening most of the multiplex but not Theater 9, where the shooting took place. As Stephanie Swanson, another visitor to the memorial, put it: "To go there, in my eyes, is kind of like dancing on people's graves."

Officials at Cinemark, which owns the Century 16, declined to discuss their plans.

Battlefields and sites that embody cherished ideals, such as bravery and self-sacrifice, have long been preserved. What has changed, said Kenneth Foote, a geography profession at the University of Colorado, Boulder, is how society marks the sites of senseless violence. In the past, communities often tried to wipe out all traces of such crimes.

"They're so shocking and shameful that people wanted to remove evidence they happened," said Foote, who wrote the book "Shadowed Ground: America's Landscapes of Violence and Tragedy."

These days the question often isn't whether the dead will be memorialized, but how. "This is the last place these people were alive, so that's very powerful," Foote said.

As with the site of the World Trade Center, choosing a tribute can be a lengthy and contentious process. When Greg Zanis, an Illinois man behind the Aurora crosses, erected a similar memorial for victims of the 1999 shootings at Columbine High in nearby Littleton, he received angry calls for including crosses for the two young killers.

Zanis took down the memorial, but other Coloradans begged him to reconsider. He returned 13 crosses -- for the 12 students and one teacher killed -- to their original spot and found a new site for the shooters' crosses. "After all," he said at the time, "they have families who mourn them, too."

After some debate, the idea of tearing down the school was rejected. "Many people felt that if we destroyed Columbine High School, then the two murderers had won," said principal Frank DeAngelis.

The library where many of the killings occurred was sealed off with drywall and lockers, but DeAngelis knew from personal experience that would not be enough.

A committee, which included victims' families, decided to convert the library and cafeteria below it into an atrium-like open space with a giant ceiling mural of aspen trees and 13 clouds.

A new library was built, and a formal memorial was created in a nearby park where Zanis erected those first crosses.

Victims' families were also consulted about what to do at Virginia Tech where 32 people were killed in a 2007 shooting.

The university reopened Norris Hall, but the second floor, where many died, was converted into a Center for Peace Studies and Violence Prevention.

In Tucson, Ariz., in January, a small memorial was unveiled outside the Safeway store where a gunman fired into a crowd waiting to meet then-Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, killing six people.

© 2018 Star Tribune