National sweetener battle grows increasingly bitter

  • Article by: JIM SPENCER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: July 12, 2014 - 5:55 PM

Minnesota ag titans Cargill and American Crystal Sugar face off in a legal fight that even doctors say isn’t about public health.


Five-pound bags of table sugar from beets are filled at American Crystal Sugar Company in Moorhead.

Photo: Glen Stubbe, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

David Berg, the CEO of Moorhead-based American Crystal Sugar Co., swears he has nothing “useful or relevant” to offer to a long-running lawsuit that pits the refined sugar industry against the high-fructose corn syrup industry.

Minnetonka-based agri-giant Cargill Inc. and other corn syrup producers want to depose Berg after being sued by sugar groups over marketing claims. The syrup producers say Berg helped hatch plans to “vilify” the corn syrup industry as a director of the Sugar Association, even though American Crystal, the nation’s largest beet sugar producer, dropped out of the trade group to avoid litigation filed in 2011.

The maneuvering is part of a multimillion-dollar legal battle for the nation’s multibillion-dollar sweetener market. At issue is whether corn syrup is nutritionally the same as sugar, as the syrup makers assert, or a less natural product that is inherently less healthy.

The feud has led two of Minnesota’s agricultural titans to increasingly take aim at each other in what some observers see as a fight for sales, not consumers’ well-being. Walter Willett, who chairs the nutrition department at Harvard’s School of Public Health, calls the sweetener war “a struggle over market share” in a “game among industry giants.”

In a new legal filing last week, corn syrup lawyers offered internal communications Berg wrote that called for the sugar industry “to delay or stop” the U.S. Food and Drug Administration from designating high fructose corn syrup as “corn sugar.” In those memos, Berg said that sugar groups should obstruct the syrup industry “with blunt force, or degrees of finesse, but we have to oppose them.”

American Crystal, which had $1.6 billion in 2013 revenue, did not respond to a request for information on Berg’s involvement in any campaign to discredit corn syrup.

Cargill, a private company that derived an unknown share of its $2.3 billion 2013 profits from milling corn into syrup, deferred comment on Berg’s subpoena to a co-defendant, the Corn Refiners Association.

“We have endeavored to gather information relating to these matters from other representatives of the Sugar Association, but they have disclaimed knowledge and claimed not to be able to recall relevant facts and events,” Corn Refiners President John Bode said in an e-mail to the Star Tribune.

Adam Fox, a lawyer for sugar groups involved in the suit, predicted that Berg will not be deposed because the deadline for submitting facts discovered in the case was June 30. Fox also accused Cargill and other large agribusinesses, including Archer Daniels Midland, of trying to hoodwink consumers by forming a group called “Sweet Surprise.”

Fox says the group undertook a “$100 million advertising campaign to convince the American people that high-fructose corn syrup is natural” and “no different than sugar.” Fox called the claims false and misleading.

The Sweet Surprise website includes blog entries with titles such as “Fructose and Causes of Obesity: The data shows poor link.” It features articles like “The Media and Food Fears,” which begins, “In recent years, [high-fructose corn syrup] has been singled out in the media as the main cause of obesity and other health problems even though there is no conclusive scientific evidence to support such allegations.”

Meanwhile, corn syrup defenders say communications obtained in the lawsuit expose the sugar industry’s financing of research and planting of news stories aimed solely at the “vilification” of corn syrup. One 2004 memo from Sugar Association President Andrew Briscoe explains that the trade group has “fed the media with the science to help fuel the public concern and debate on [high-fructose corn syrup].”

By 2008, Briscoe explains that efforts to bring troubling scientific information to the academic community and the media “has helped to connect the dots and help clarify [high-fructose corn syrup] and all free-fructose corn-based sweeteners as a concern.” Briscoe cites decreases in corn syrup deliveries and increases in raw sugar deliveries as proof.

Heavy consumption

With some research showing Americans consuming 15 times as many sweeteners as they did in the 18th century, public health specialists call the lawsuit an exercise in picking your poison.

“The truth is we’re having a problem consuming pharmacologic doses of sugar in any form over the past decade,” said Dr. Mark Hyman, a physician specializing in ways lifestyles and environment affect health.

Doctors say the distinctions being debated are unlikely to benefit consumers. Mary Schmidl, a professor in the University of Minnesota’s department of food science and nutrition, said the suit is “about two organizations that both make similar products and want to provide ‘sugars’ to the general public.”

There are differences in the chemical content of refined sugar and high-fructose corn syrup. Sweeteners are made up of fructose and glucose. In sugar, the two elements are chemically bonded in a 50-50 ratio. High-fructose corn syrup has no chemical bond between fructose and glucose and contains more free fructose than free glucose — anywhere from 55 to 75 percent, according to Hyman.

  • related content

  • Signage for Cargill Inc. is displayed at their booth at the Institute of Food Technologists Annual Meeting & Food Expo In Chicago, Illinois, U.S., on Monday, July 19, 2010. The meeting brings together professionals from the science and business sectors of the food industry to learn about the newest trends and products. Photographer: Tim Boyle/Bloomberg

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters