StarTribune.com
stpirv110509

Home | Politically Connected | Local Politics

Ranked-choice voting opponents have day in court

A group opposing ranked-choice voting has alleged that the group that pushed for the new voting system in St. Paul used deceptive campaign practices.

Last update: November 4, 2009 - 9:17 PM

The two sides involved in a campaign dispute over mailings that supported ranked-choice voting in St. Paul made their arguments to an administrative law judge on Wednesday.

Administrative Law Judge Kathleen Sheehy will have three days to decide whether there's enough evidence to warrant another hearing.

A day earlier, voters in St. Paul approved changing to the ranked-choice system for electing their mayor and City Council members. Supporters cast 52.4 percent of the votes.

The opposition -- No Bad Ballots political committee -- filed complaints in the past week against the St. Paul Better Ballot Campaign, which pushed for the new voting method.

The opponents of ranked-choice allege that the Better Ballot group falsely claimed support from various parties, including the League of Women Voters and President Obama, on mailings sent to voters.

"There's nothing false in the literature," said Jay Benanav, an attorney representing the Better Ballot group.

Chuck Repke of the No Bad Ballots group disagreed.

The essence of the complaint, he said, is that the Better Ballot group didn't get specific endorsement from groups or signatures of support from people whose credibility could sway voter opinion.

"Nobody cares if Chuck Repke supports something, but Barack Obama has curb appeal," Repke said.

Benanav said he's confident the judge will find all the statements true.

Even if that's not the case, Benanav said, the election results won't change.

In the case of the League of Women Voters, officials from that group have said that while they support both the current plurality system of voting and ranked-choice voting, the league doesn't endorse candidates or campaigns.

Still, the Better Ballot folks said the state and city LWV support ranked-choice voting as an option, and that was the basis for the language on the mailings.

Chris Havens • 612-673-4148

Recent Local Politics stories

Election judges take matters in hand to determine close races - November 4, 2009
Election judges take matters in hand to determine close races - Though sometimes called instant-runoff voting, it's anything but. Votes are being counted by hand in cases where no one won 50 percent plus one vote. More
Voters register opposing views on tax increases - November 4, 2009

Comment on this story   |   Read all 18 comments   |  Hide reader comments


Subscribe

Current state office holders

Governor: Tim Pawlenty
One of only a few prominent Republicans to win a competitive re-election contest in the Democratic sweep of 2006, Tim Pawlenty is widely seen as politically shrewd and naturally likable.

Minnesota's political giants: Learn more about the men and women who have shaped Minnesota's political history.

Shopping + Classifieds
Homes

1000s of Homes

Listings, open houses, the hottest market news. Start and end your search for a new home here.
Foreclosures

Home For Sale

Learn the best way to buy and sell a home. Start now!

Win tickets to The Midnight Movie Society's screening of "Clue" at Red Stag Supperclub.

Vita.mn and DJ Jake Rudh present the first meeting of The Midnight Movie Society at Red Stag Supperclub on Dec. 4, with drinking, dancing and a midnight screening of cult-classic film, "Clue."

See all contests