Shrinking Minnesota budget would be first since '86

  • Article by: PATRICIA LOPEZ , Star Tribune
  • Updated: January 27, 2009 - 11:05 PM

Pawlenty says state must do more than erase $4.8 billion deficit, but some will see a heavy cost.

hide

Gov. Tim Pawlenty announced on Tuesday his budget proposal for 2010-11. At $33.6 billion, it would be 2.2 percent less than the current budget, but it would increase spending for K-12 education and cut business taxes in half.

Photo: David Joles, Star Tribune

CartBuy Photos

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

  • share

    email

Nearly 85,000 working Minnesotans would lose their health care, while cities, counties, colleges and universities would see funding cuts in the first proposal in a generation to make year-to-year reductions in the state's budget.

The spartan 2010-11 budget proposed Tuesday by Gov. Tim Pawlenty would erase a $4.8 billion projected deficit and cut business taxes, but at a heavy cost to some Minnesotans.

To stanch the flow of red ink, Pawlenty would slash projected spending by $2.4 billion, employ nearly $1.3 billion in accounting shifts and, in an unexpected move, sell bonds that wring a one-time cash infusion from the state's yearly tobacco settlement funds.

The bonds, if they could be sold in today's flat-lined market, would bring in nearly $1 billion in revenue to help patch the state through what's expected to be a rough couple of years.

"This is a set of circumstances that I think is going to linger," Pawlenty said during his official budget release. But, he said, the state must do more than balance the bottom line in hard times. "This debate is not about where Minnesota is currently. It's about where Minnesota is headed."

To that end, Pawlenty said he will insist on halving the state's business taxes -- a move that will cost state coffers $287 million in the short run but which Pawlenty said will spark job growth.

Pawlenty is also counting on at least $920 million in federal stimulus funds to help the state out of its deficit hole. The figure is actually expected to be much higher -- about $3 billion or more -- but Pawlenty pointed out that fully half that money may go to "shovel-ready" projects that will benefit the state's economy, but not its budget. Whatever additional money comes in, he said, could serve as a cushion against the deeper declines expected in coming months.

The proposed budget is 2.2 percent smaller than the budget for the current biennium. The last time the state faced an actual year-to-year reduction in the budget -- as opposed to a reduction from projected levels -- was 1986, amid a recession that hit Minnesota's economy hard. The 2.2 percent reduction is more than the 1.5 percent reduction of 1986, but nowhere near as steep as the 17 percent year-to-year hit in 1983.

Tuesday's proposal -- which got a chilly reception from the DFL-controlled Legislature -- includes larger goals of Pawlenty's that he has attempted before without success centering on performance-based funding. K-12 schools, for instance, could tap an extra $300 per pupil if they move to Pawlenty's pay-for-performance structure known as Q Comp.

As promised, Pawlenty delivered a hard blow to counties, cities and townships -- a 10 to 15 percent reduction in projected subsidies known as local government aid. For some local governments, the aid supplies more than half their revenue. Mayors gathered in St. Paul on Tuesday called the proposed reductions "devastating" to already-reeling cities.

DFL leaders, who, unlike GOP leaders, were not given an advance briefing on the budget, were left groping for details on a plan that few had been able to review. "The devil's in the details, and we have no details," said House Majority Leader Tony Sertich, DFL-Chisholm.

Senate Majority Leader Larry Pogemiller, DFL-Minneapolis, said the Senate would "work with the governor's budget as seriously as we can," but said that throwing people off health care in a severe recession was "probably not a smart or nice thing to do."

Pawlenty said that he was not without empathy and that he had faced similar challenges. "My mom passed away when I was in high school," he said. "Not too long after that my dad lost his job for a while, and we as a family had a very upfront and personal look at what it means to face economic challenge and economic anxiety." The answer to hard times, Pawlenty said, was to balance the budget and prepare for the future.

Critics said that not everyone will share in the pain.

Minnesota AFL-CIO President Ray Waldron called Pawlenty's proposal "the most cynical budget ever. This guy sounds so good that you almost forget his budget kicks struggling Minnesotans while they are down."

Pawlenty has ruled out tax increases, saying that a higher income tax would yield too little and risk driving away capital while higher business taxes would make the state even more uncompetitive.

The budget-balancing task is complicated by two unknowns: the exact size and scope of the federal bailout that should come together in the next few weeks, and a state economic forecast coming March 3 that is almost certain to show another big drop in projected revenues.

Tuesday's proposal will be the first salvo in what is expected to be a contentious legislative session, as the Republican governor tussles with the DFL-controlled Legislature, where leaders argue that revenue increases should be in the mix.

Staff writer Mark Brunswick contributed to this report. Patricia Lopez • 651-222-1288

  • related content

  • K-12 feels lucky with funding increases

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 8:57 PM

    Schools lucked out in the governor's budget, winning funding increases at a time when overall state spending would be cut. And DFLers generally approve.

  • Losses loom for adults without children

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:02 PM

    About 55,000 Minnesotans would lose health care coverage this year and another 29,000 next year under Gov. Tim Pawlenty's proposed two-year budget.

  • Seeing a familiar plan and fewer options

    Last update: Wednesday January 28, 2009 - 10:37 AM

    Some education officials are suffering from flashbacks.

  • A debate ahead over what services to cut

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:08 PM

    Gov. Tim Pawlenty's budget proposal takes another big swipe at local government aid (LGA), cutting it by 15 percent in the 2009 calendar year and 31 percent in 2010, compared with current law. Last month, Pawlenty sliced the December LGA payment by 22 percent to fix a short-term budget problem.

  • Selling bonds to deal with debt service

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:08 PM

    Twice before, Gov. Tim Pawlenty has turned to tobacco to help balance the state's books. In 2003, he tapped a billion-dollar endowment left over from the 1998 tobacco lawsuit settlement to help resolve a large budget shortfall. In 2005 he proposed a "health impact fee" on cigarettes to help end a partial state government shutdown and reach an agreement on that year's budget. This year, tobacco again plays a role in the proposed budget solution. Here's how:

  • Proposal would halve business tax rate

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:10 PM

    Gov. Tim Pawlenty's budget includes tax cuts and credits that he says will create jobs and help businesses. The governor proposed reducing the business tax rate from 9.8 percent to 4.8 percent over six years. He also wants to provide an up-front exemption of the sales tax for purchases of capital equipment and a tax credit for small businesses purchasing machinery and equipment.

  • MnDOT not insulated from fiscal pain

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:14 PM

    The Minnesota Department of Transportation gets nearly all of its funding from gas tax revenues, vehicle registration fees, vehicle sales taxes and federal outlays, so the agency is largely on the sidelines during the deficit crisis. Transportation makes up only 1.1 percent of the governor's proposed general-fund expenditures.

  • Pawlenty's budget would ...

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:52 PM

    SPEND $33.6 billion in 2010-11 ... ELIMINATE a projected $4.8 billion deficit ... CUT $2.4 billion in projected spending, including $1.3 billion from health and human services, $522 million from local government aid, $313 million from higher education ... SHIFT $1.3 billion in K-12 payments ... INCREASE K-12 school funding by up to $156 million, largely tied to student achievement and Q Comp teacher compensation ... BORROW $1 billion via bonds tied to tobacco payments ... COUNT ON $920 million in federal stimulus money ... and REDUCE business taxes by $287 million.

  • Spending reductions*

    Last update: Tuesday January 27, 2009 - 9:51 PM

    Health and human services $1.3 billion Aid to local governments $522 million Higher education $313 million...

  • 6

  • share

    email

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close