Readers Write (Feb. 21): Education benefits, housing crisis, orchestra

  • Article by: STAR TRIBUNE READERS
  • Updated: February 20, 2013 - 7:36 PM
hide

Photo: file, Tribune Media Services

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

EDUCATION BENEFITS

Graduate income is a helpful data set

In “Education customers deserve a positive return” (Business Forum, Feb. 18), Fred Zimmerman asks: “Are our customers making any money?”

That’s an excellent question. And I’d like to add: “If so, how will we know?”

Historically, the only tool for colleges and universities to understand the earnings of their graduates has been self-reported alumni surveys. Now, as a result of the federal government’s release of income data for the graduates of hundreds of institutions, any potential student who wants to get an MBA in finance can know exactly what graduates from that program earned on average, which in the case of Capella University for the 2010 tax year is $95,459.

The problem is that this kind of data has been made available only for a limited number of colleges. The federal government, or even the state of Minnesota, could take a significant step to help consumers by making this data available on a voluntary basis to any institution seeking the income data of its graduates on a program-by-program basis.

SCOTT KINNEY, Minneapolis

The writer is president of Capella University.

• • •

Hold on just a minute — about a lot of hours.

In his commentary, Zimmerman stated: “While many people labor 2,000 hours in a single year, the classroom contact hours among high school teachers is around 865 hours while summers and other periods are free.”

Although at first it might seem weak, a more legitimate comparison is between professional athletes and high school teachers. If we apply Zimmerman’s logic, most NFL football players work 60 hours a year (20 games that are about three hours long). Forget training, practice, work with the public, planning in coaches’ classrooms, individual film study or dealing with injuries.

Interestingly, Zimmerman gives college professors credit for responsibilities such as class preparation and student counseling, but doesn’t mention those or any of the additional time-consuming activities high school teachers experience.

Just for examples, consider the effort necessary to evaluate and grade students’ work; communicate with parents; prepare for and attend meetings; share ideas and concerns with other teachers; tutor students needing extra help; supervise and guide students beyond the time in regular classes; consult with administrators, counselors and other support personnel; make a classroom itself appealing and functional; order and possibly beg for supplies, plus deal with the frustrations and even dangers of disciplining students.

By the way, most of the summer Zimmerman references is either for uncompensated seasonal unemployment, part-time work or a teacher’s continuing education.

I assume there’s no need to compare the incomes of NFL players and teachers.

JIM BARTOS, Brooklyn Park

 • • •

RATINGS AGENCIES 

S&P acted in good faith on housing

Assertions that we compromised our analytic integrity for business considerations (“Franken urges new rules for rating agencies,” Feb. 15) are simply false. We deeply regret that our CDO ratings failed to fully anticipate the rapidly deteriorating conditions in the U.S. mortgage market in the time leading up to the financial crisis.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

  • about opinion

  • The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.

  • Submit a letter or commentary
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close