It's a matter of health, but revenue gains would be significant.
A poised University of Minnesota student testified at the State Capitol this week about the impact her father's death to esophageal cancer had on her life. He was a smoker who died prematurely when she was just 14.
"He wasn't there when I graduated from high school," said Kaila Narum of Andover. "And I won't get a father-daughter dance at my wedding."
Narum was the youngest and most powerful of nine witnesses who urged legislators to raise cigarette taxes as a matter of public health. It's a measure supported by this page; numerous studies show that high cigarette prices motivate adults to cut back or quit smoking -- and deter young people from ever starting.
For some of the same reasons, the 2013 Legislature also should raise taxes on alcohol sales. Alcohol-related costs to the state are staggering -- millions more than the tax revenues currently collected from sales, according to the Minnesota Department of Health.
While the tobacco lobby is formidable, Minnesota's liquor lobbyists have seemed invincible. Two years ago, they helped shoot down a two-penny-a-drink statewide liquor tax proposed by St. Paul Mayor Chris Coleman. The tax would have raised $48 million a year, some of which Coleman proposed using to fund the public cost of the Vikings stadium.
Gov. Mark Dayton wants to raise the state's cigarette tax by 94 cents per pack, which he says will generate $370 million in revenue over two years even with a projected decrease in total sales. But Rep. Ann Lenczewski, DFL-Bloomington, is calling for a $1.60-per-pack increase, which would raise $440 million. In the Senate, Minority Leader Carla Nelson, R-Rochester, is proposing a $1.29-a-pack hike.
A coalition of 30 health and other groups, including the Mayo Clinic and HealthPartners, support the tax hikes. They say increasing prices by at least $1.50 per pack would save more than 25,000 lives and about $1.65 billion in long-term tobacco-related health costs to the state. Michael Bromelkamp, a CPA and principal with Olsen Thielen in St. Paul, told the House Taxes Committee that Minnesota employers lose nearly $3,400 for every employee who smokes because of higher health care costs, missed work and lower productivity.
Minnesota's tobacco statistics are grim: 5,100 residents die annually from tobacco-related illness, some 53,000 high school students smoke daily and 77,000 young people will try tobacco this year. Dr. Courtney Jordan Baechler, a cardiologist, told lawmakers that one-third of those who become regular smokers will eventually die because of it.
That's why measures championed by Nelson and Rep. Jenifer Loon, R-Eden Prairie, who seek to close the loophole on so-called "little cigars," also deserve support. The fruit-flavored "cigars" look like cigarettes but cost less and are marketed to young people as a means to get them hooked on tobacco.
"Youth, students, kids like me are price-sensitive," Narum testified. "When the price of something is increased dramatically, we can't afford to buy it."
Opponents argue that higher cigarette taxes will hurt the poor and small retail businesses and lead to a larger black market for smugglers. But lawmakers in other states are finding creative ways to deter cigarette smuggling.
It's also worth noting that smoking rates are higher among minorities and lower-income groups, and they have fewer resources to tap when health problems arise. "Higher tobacco taxes will benefit rather than harm our communities," testified Gloria Cazanacli of La Oportunidad, an area outreach agency for Latino youth and families.
The same can be said of Minnesota's young people, as Kaila Narum reinforced Thursday with a critical question for legislators to ponder in the weeks ahead: "Will you protect Minnesota kids or the tobacco industry?"
An editorial of of the Star Tribune, Minneapolis.
The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.