At New York’s new September 11 museum, you can buy a 9/11 magnet — or not.
Mementos of loved ones lost in the 9/ 11 attacks are now on display at the National September 11 Memorial Museum in New York. Donated by family members, the many small personal effects of victims are among the most poignant and difficult artifacts in a museum that may present an emotionally overwhelming experience for guests.
When it comes to tragedy, there’s a thin line between solemn commemoration and crass commercialization. It’s crossed all the time.
The New York Post recently reported that relatives of 9/11 victims are outraged that the National September 11 Memorial Museum will be home to a gift shop that peddles T-shirts, mugs and rescue-dog vests, as well as books and other educational material relating to the deadly terrorist attack.
“To me, it’s the crassest, most insensitive thing to have a commercial enterprise at the place where my son died,” the mother of one victim told the Post.
The visceral response of a parent who will always feel the agony of loss is understandable. But as a ThinkProgress article points out, museums dedicated to all sorts of tragedies — from the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum to the Oklahoma City Museum, which commemorates a domestic terrorist attack — have gift shops.
Indeed, as the article notes, not having a museum shop would be the aberration. The commercialization of tragedy is not just a U.S. phenomenon. There’s a bookstore at the Auschwitz-Birkenau museum, and souvenirs are available at the Anne Frank House.
Museums rely on these shops for revenue. According to Sept. 11 memorial officials, the nonprofit relies on private fundraising, donations, ticket revenue and “carefully selected keepsake items for retail.” And it is not alone when it comes to the tragedy trade.
Two days after the Boston Marathon bombing, the Daily Mail reported that the U.S. Patent and Trademark office received applications from two retailers rushing to market the “Boston Strong” slogan. Since then, “Boston Strong” has morphed into its own hashtag, and the slogan is used to sell T-shirts and hats, among a plethora of products. In some (but not all) cases, proceeds are donated to marathon-bombing-related charities.
A profit motive connected to tragedy is definitely offensive to some. New York magazine reported on a social media backlash to holiday ornaments and dog sweaters commemorating Hurricane Sandy. And the abundance of Boston Marathon-related merchandise has led to people asking if “Boston Strong” has gone too far.
But what’s offensive to some is fine with others, or retailers wouldn’t roll the taste dice. After all, no one’s forcing anyone to buy a Boston Strong bracelet or a 9/11 magnet.
A few weeks ago, I visited the Sept. 11 memorial site. Even without access to the museum, which is just now opening, the emotional impact was enormous. It feels like the sacred ground it is to those who lost loved ones. As the official memorial plaza website explains, the name of every person who died in the terrorist attacks of Feb. 26, 1993, and Sept. 11, 2001, is inscribed in bronze around twin memorial ponds, which sit within the footprints where the twin towers once stood. It’s at once intimate and massive. One World Trade Center — also known as the Freedom Tower — soars nearby.
Throngs of visitors quietly took it all in that weekend. But, of course, being tourists, they also took pictures of one another, just as if they were standing in front of the Grand Canyon or the Eiffel Tower. The exit path took us directly past the gift shop that existed before the museum even opened. The natural instinct was to enter what the Post called the “Little Shop of Horror,” but might more accurately be dubbed a shop of knickknacks.
As a dog lover, I was tempted by a book profiling rescue dogs who tirelessly worked the 9/11 site in search of victims. But in the end, I didn’t buy anything. It just didn’t feel right.
That’s the choice we all have in a free society built on capitalism — and on the right to be outraged by it or not.
The Opinion section is produced by the Editorial Department to foster discussion about key issues. The Editorial Board represents the institutional voice of the Star Tribune and operates independently of the newsroom.