New levy to pay for $9 million ash tree removal in Minneapolis

  • Article by: BILL MCAULIFFE , Star Tribune
  • Updated: December 10, 2013 - 8:51 PM

A new tax levy will generate funding for the systematic replacement of the bug-plagued trees, starting next year.


After Douglas Moberg made final cuts, a skid loader pushed over an ash tree at the city’s Gross National Golf Club. Crews will remove 92 trees there this winter.

Photo: Bruce Bisping •,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger


An eight-year-long goodbye to ash trees in Minneapolis will start up in 2014, as the city begins a $9 million project to take down 40,000 ash trees in the city’s parks and on its boulevards and golf courses.

Armed with a just-approved tax levy specifically designed to blunt the impact of the deadly emerald ash borer, foresters will remove 3,000 ash from city boulevards, parks and golf courses in 2014, and possibly up to 5,000 for each of the following seven years. About 20 percent of all Minneapolis trees are ash.

“It will look different,” said Park and Recreation Board President John Erwin, noting how the urban forest will have more types of trees than it does now, which is due to a historic reliance on a few popular species. That approach left the tree population vulnerable to mass die-offs due to bugs and diseases.

“It’s a very good thing,” said Erwin, a University of Minnesota horticulture professor. “We’re never going to have this situation again that we’ve had with Dutch elm or the emerald ash borer.”

Once the trees are all down, the only ash trees left will be the few on public and private property that either have been chemically treated or have somehow managed to avoid being infested by the tiny green beetle that has spread largely unchecked across North America for 20-plus years, killing every untreated ash it has met.

Ralph Sievert, head of forestry services for the Park Board, said the removal-and-replacement plan is built on the idea that ash trees are, for now, a doomed species whose demise can be managed, economically and aesthetically.

“That’s all assuming the beetle doesn’t go crazy and start killing a lot of ash all at once,” he said.

Not clear-cutting

The levy backing up the canopy replacement plan will kick in Jan. 1 and generate about $1.1 million per year. It will cost the owner of an average-value home $8 each year, Erwin said. The Park Board has removed nearly 5,000 ash trees from boulevards, parks and golf courses since 2010, using its existing funds.

The special tax levy will have to be renewed each year. A Park Board committee last week approved it as part of its overall $66 million budget for 2014, which represents no increase in the board’s operating fund, but it does include $1.1 million specifically to remove and replace ash trees on city boulevards and in parks and on golf courses. The budget is expected to get final approval on Wednesday at City Hall.

Despite the number of trees coming down, Erwin and Sievert say that the plan isn’t exactly clear-cutting.

The Park Board already clears away 5,000 trees of all species in an average year. Ash removals could approach 5,000 in future years with the new levy, but foresters will cut no more than 20 percent of any block’s trees in one year and will go after other ash trees that are damaged or in locations where they wouldn’t grow well anyway.

In 2014, removals likely will be concentrated in the eastern part of the city, where infestations have been detected, and move west, Erwin said.

Sievert said that if residents ask that an ash on public property be removed so a replacement can get started, foresters will take it out and replace it with another species.

Treat or cut?

Residents also can arrange for ash trees on boulevards and in parks and on golf courses to be treated with insecticide, although that requires hiring a Park Board-approved company to do the injecting.

Those residents — not the Park Board — would then be on the hook for continuing treatments costing $150 to $250 every other year. Sievert said about 75 ash were treated citywide with insecticide this year.

  • related content

  • Aug. 8: Ash borer treatments costing less, working better

    Thursday August 8, 2013

    The destructive insect, first detected here in 2009, has been found in Hennepin, Ramsey, Winona and Houston counties but still hasn’t reached peak infestation in Minnesota, giving cities time to...

  • July 18: Tying green ribbons on the old ash tree

    Thursday July 18, 2013

    Information campaign involves putting green ribbons on trees threatened by ash borer.

  • Douglas Moberg of the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board used a chain saw to cut down another ash tree on the city’s Gross National Golf Club last week.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters