StarTribune.com
tuition011909

Home | Local + Metro

Economy hitting private schools hard

Lost jobs mean parents can't afford tuition just as big donors pull back because of their stock market losses.

Last update: January 18, 2009 - 10:26 PM

While public schools brace for bad news from state politicians because of the budget deficit, private schools already have gotten word from their own chief funders -- the parents of their students.

Minnesota has more than 500 private schools with combined enrollment of 80,000 students, according to the Minnesota Department of Education. Almost all of them have reason to be concerned about their finances in the coming months.

The epidemic of layoffs and a deepening recession mean that private schools are worrying that job losses or fears of job losses will prevent families from meeting tuition payments or convince them they can't afford a private education.

Some are like Michaela Bisanz, who put two of her kids through Catholic schools and has two more enrolled. Bisanz has been through a divorce, and her former spouse has lost a job, but for now she is keeping her daughter at Cretin-Derham Hall and her son at Highland Catholic School, both in St. Paul.

"I want to give my kids every opportunity I can to learn about their faith," said Bisanz, who lives in St. Paul. "It's more important to us, I guess, than a new car or vacations."

The crunch has schools closely considering their annual tuition increases, tapping perennial donors to give more and stepping up marketing to persuade families that private schools remain good bargains.

"The fear is that, if unemployment increases next year, it could significantly affect enrollment in the following year," said Terry Campbell, administrator at New Life Academy, a Christian school in Woodbury. "Also, we are having a few families facing layoffs, and they are beginning to question their ability to pay tuition."

Most private schools will get a better picture of next fall's attendance over the next few weeks as they begin taking enrollment applications.

The biggest effect on the schools thus far is a higher level of financial aid requests, say private school officials. The need is increasing at the same time that donors are curtailing their giving, often because of stock market losses.

New Life Academy, for example, is certain to fall short of the $150,000 goal for its annual fundraising, which it uses to subsidize tuition for some of its 655 students. That's a small drop in the bucket of the $4 million it collects annually from tuition, which averages $7,000 a year.

Family help

The fund that Cretin-Derham Hall uses to help subsidize tuition is down because of the sharp stock market decline, said Richard Engler, president and principal of the school. "We're looking at a smaller increase in tuition than normal," Engler said. "But also smaller increases in salary and benefits."

Ray Levi, head of Minneapolis Jewish Day School, a K-8 institution in St. Louis Park, said his school is responding by increasing its fundraising efforts.

"We are again trying to remind our donors that, particularly during a period of economic uncertainty, we want to be able to continue to serve families and that to provide tuition assistance dollars is really critical." The school's annual tuition is $10,500 to $12,000.

Some parents have begun tapping their own parents, school officials say.

"More grandparents are helping out with tuition than ever before," says Allen Labitzky, principal at King of Grace Lutheran School in Golden Valley. Other grandparents are playing the secret Santa role and dropping by the school with checks to be applied to their grandchildren's accounts, Labitzky said.

That's how Bisanz is making do -- with help from her family and community through donations made to Cretin-Derham's education foundation to pay the school's $9,300 annual tuition.

Barb Hawn of Woodbury has put two of her own kids through New Life Academy, hosted an international student who graduated from the school, and now has a ninth-grader there and is hosting another international student at the school. Tuition at New Life, "would be one the last thing I would sacrifice," says Hawn, because the school lays a strong religious, values and education foundation for its students.

Marketing themselves

Helping with tuition is one thing. Marketing themselves is another strategy private schools are employing.

Last fall, Mount Hope-Redemption Lutheran School in Bloomington made its first mass marketing push by sending full color fliers stressing their values-laden education to 30,000 homes in Bloomington, Burnsville and Eagan.

"You definitely feel the impact" of the recession, said Principal David Polzin. "Enrollment is down."

The Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, which includes 103 schools in the state, has strengthened is marketing campaign by taking out billboards locally that read: "You can afford a Catholic education."

It has also added radio ads in addition to its annual television advertising campaign, telling viewers that the schools "integrate faith, service and academic excellence," and inviting them to visit a school.

The archdiocese also has hired a full-time marketing person to work with the schools to improve their websites and to better identify potential student families.

"We're going to keep these schools affordable, accessible and viable," said Marty Frauenheim, the archdiocese's superintendent of education.

Similarly, most schools are sounding optimistic.

"We have to make sure our parents see us as a value so that it is one of the last things they would consider cutting out of the family budget," said Campbell, of New Life. "I think all of us are praying extra hard."

Gregory A. Patterson • 651-298-1546

Recent Local + Metro stories

Keillor performance to be beamed to movie theaters - January 18, 2009
Keillor performance to be beamed to movie theaters - It may be the next best thing to seeing Garrison Keillor's "A Prairie Home Companion" live. More

Comments are temporarily unavailable

Our reader comments feature is currently undergoing maintenance. Please check back to comment on this story and join the discussion. We apologize for any inconvenience.
Subscribe
Shopping + Classifieds
Personal Recruiter

No resume? No problem!

Create a skills profile in minutes, let a recruiter match you to an open position. Click here to get started.
Find A Job

Open positions!

A new career awaits. Look through thousands of listings to find your new job. Start now!

Win tickets to see Brett Dennen at Pantages Theatre.

Vita.mn presents Brett Dennen with Grace Potter and The Nocturnals at Pantages Theatre on Nov. 27.

See all contests