Previous Page 4 of 6 Next

Continued: Eric Dean: The boy they couldn't save

  • Article by: BRANDON STAHL , Star Tribune
  • Last update: September 1, 2014 - 2:38 PM

Eric told her he bit himself. DeGeer reported it to the county.

That same day, Myslicki filed her first report, that she saw facial bruises and bite marks on Eric’s cheek and ear, which was bleeding.

“Mom coached Eric into saying he hurt himself,” she told the county.

Rather than determine whether abuse happened, the county referred the family to a state program known as family assessment. Made state law nearly a decade ago, the program tries to teach adults to be better parents. The program is intended only for children in “low-risk” situations, but family assessment has become so prevalent in Minnesota that it’s now used by counties in lieu of investigation more than 70 percent of the time.

And unlike investigation, in which child-protection workers determine whether abuse or neglect occurred, family assessment is voluntary.

The assessment was assigned to Lurken-Tvrdik. She went to the home and took photos of Eric, which showed bruises to his left ear, his forehead, his right cheek and under his right eye, and a scab above his lip. Unlike the last time she saw Eric, he wouldn’t talk or look at her.

“He looked very sad,” Lurken-Tvrdik later testified in court. “Yes, I definitely saw a change.”

Dean and Peltier declined help from the county, which closed the case.

The next week, Eric came to day care with a bruised face and neck, a bleeding right ear and a fat lip. Myslicki alerted child protection once again, and the county screened out that report.

Myslicki began keeping a log of the boy’s injuries. On Feb. 14: black and blue marks on his forehead. Feb. 22: swollen left cheek and a left black eye. The next day: bruises on his right cheek starting to turn black and blue. The day after that: more bruises on his forehead and nose.

The log was enough to get the county to open another family assessment case, Eric’s third in his three years of life.

On March 13, 2012, Lurken-Tvrdik and another county child-protection worker, Amy Beckius, met again with Peltier at her Starbuck home. This time, Eric’s father was there.

Though Peltier did most of the talking, she and Dean both told the child-protection workers that they never laid a hand on any of their children. Peltier told them what she told day-care providers: Eric’s injuries were largely a result of his own doing. The bites, she said, came from other kids, including their 6-month-old son.

Eric’s grandparents told the social workers they saw no signs of abuse. Eric’s siblings also said their parents didn’t physically punish them.

A week after Peltier and Dean met with child protection, Eric went for a checkup at Glenwood Medical Center. His nurse practitioner said there was no medical explanation for the boy’s bruises.

The county identified Eric as high-risk for more maltreatment, then closed the case on April 5, 2012.

“It would appear,” Beckius wrote, “that the family is willing to access what services are needed for Eric and they continue to deny any physical means of punishment to Eric... .”

At day care, Myslicki said the signs of abuse stopped for a few months until one morning in August 2012. Peltier was furious with Eric when she came to pick him up, Myslicki said. The boy cowered as Myslicki held on to him. Peltier slapped Eric out of her hands, knocking him to the floor, and yelled at him to get his shoes on, according to Myslicki.

  • related content

  • A note on sources

    Saturday August 30, 2014

    This story is based on a review of thousands of pages of police, child-protection and court records, including from Amanda...

  • State misses chances to save abused kids' lives

    Sunday May 18, 2014

    In some cases, state says, counties could have done more to save children from abuse and neglect.

  • Counties 'screen out' most child abuse reports

    Sunday April 20, 2014

    Bill would require better tracking of child abuse cases that are screened out without investigation.

  • Hennepin County knew since 1993 of abuse, neglect allegations vs. Mpls. couple

    Wednesday August 20, 2014

    A Minneapolis couple were taken into custody Tuesday, five months after their newborn’s death.

  • A photograph of Eric Dean taken by his special education teacher, Mindy DeGeer, was presented by the prosecution during the trial of Amanda Peltier.

  • Eric Dean's special education teacher, Mindy DeGeer, during an interview in her Glenwood home last month.

  • Amanda Peltier was convicted of murder and sentenced to life.

  • Day-care worker Colleen Myslicki kept a log of Eric’s injuries: “It felt so hopeless.”

  • Eric’s birth mother, Sommer Kemp, wept during an interview last month.

  • A photograph of Eric Dean with his arm broken was an exhibit presented as evidence by the prosecution during the May 2014 trial of Amanda Peltier.

  • Solar powered ornaments glowed at dusk above Eric Dean's grave in the St. Paul's Lutheran Cemetery outside Lowry, Minn., last month

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters






question of the day

Poll: Grade the Vikings draft selections

Weekly Question