Lucy Laney School in Minneapolis struggles to meet standards

  • Article by: ALEJANDRA MATOS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: August 30, 2014 - 11:02 AM

Principal says new measures mean improvement is in sight.


Fifth-grader Marquese Ross raised his hand to answer a math question posed by teacher Nicole Plowman at Lucy Craft Laney Community School.

Photo: DAVID JOLES , Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Lucy Craft Laney Community School Principal Mauri Melander always braces for the release of the annual standardized testing numbers.

This year, they revealed a low point that was hard to ignore: Not a single seventh-grader at the school met state math standards last year.

Out of 33 students tested in that grade, 23 did not meet standards and 10 only partly met standards, according to state testing data released last week.

Melander said improvement takes time and there are more than a few early signs of hope. The district has bolstered classroom instruction and the test scores were not all bad. Third- to sixth-grade math scores had all improved.

But Lucy Laney had among the lowest overall test results in the state, underscoring the ongoing challenges facing an inner-city school where administrators face a relentless turnover of teachers and draw a high population of children who are homeless or have unstable housing.

Melander said the community has every right to be concerned.

“The lowlight that popped out to me right away was my seventh-grade math results,” Melander said. Those students, she said, “have struggled on their math scores every year.”

For more than a decade, a strong majority of students at Lucy Laney have been far below state and federal education standards. The school, located in Minneapolis’ Cleveland neighborhood, has become the center of numerous district initiatives that aim to increase achievement and close a stubborn and profound academic achievement gap between white and minority students.

The school’s website features pictures of visits by Minneapolis Police Chief Janeé Harteau and Minnesota Supreme Court Justice Alan Page, who spoke to eighth-graders last spring about the importance of education and succeeding in life.

In 2012, Vikings vice president Kevin Warren, the highest-ranking black business executive with an NFL team, and his wife, Greta, donated 650 backpacks filled with school supplies to Lucy Laney students.

But overall, students continue to lag badly academically. Of the 300 students who were tested, just 13 percent were proficient in math and 8 percent met reading standards last year.

High teacher turnover

Melander, who has been the principal for three years, said there are many reasons for the poor results.

The challenging classroom environment has resulted in some of the highest teacher turnover rates in the district. That often means the school is filled with first-year teachers, Melander said. Those fresh teachers are often brimming with enthusiasm, but lack the experience and seasoned teaching skills necessary for struggling students. Last year, for instance, Melander had 17 first-year teachers, a low number compared to past years.

“August is always my favorite time of year because my teachers are always so optimistic. Their goals are always aspirational,” Melander said.

Each fall students are given a test to determine a baseline for the year. Melander said most students are two to three years below grade level, and the gap widens as students get older.

“As soon as [teachers] start looking at their baseline data and as soon as they start seeing the day in and day out, they start to get a little discouraged,” she said.

Roller coaster cheer

Melander places much of her hope in her veteran teachers, who can mentor the new ones.

Sigrid Espe, an eighth-grade algebra teacher, now teaches the group of children who did not meet math standards last year.

In her class of 12, Espe taught the students about order of operations, demonstrating how to solve a math problem. Then, it was time for the class to solve one on their own.

“Stand up when you have the answer,” she told her students.

In less than 30 seconds, two students stood up, one wearing an “academic achiever” polo shirt. Espe circled the room, checking the progress of each child. In about three minutes, six students stood.

And when two students modeled their work to the class, Espe made sure to recognize them for their effort and success.

They chose from three different cheers, dubbed a roller coaster cheer, a fantastic cheer and an avid cheer. Cheers made up of wooing sounds and hand clapping came from every other student in the classroom.

Both went back to their desks, with bashful smiles as their peers cheered.

Success in co-teaching

Melander said she expects to start seeing tangible gains once a new teaching model is fully implemented this year that adds a second instructor to certain classrooms.

Every kindergarten through fifth-grade classroom teacher now has a specialized math and literacy instructor joining them.

After seeing math proficiency drop to 1.4 percent for fifth-graders in 2011, the district placed a specialized math instructor in each fifth-grade classroom.

Every year since, Lucy Laney students have seen increases in fifth-grade math scores. This year, 16.4 percent of students were proficient, the highest since 2010.

Other grade levels at Lucy Laney saw gains in math, as well. Sixth-grade math went from 2.4 percent to 10.2 percent meeting standards.

Melander is well aware that a majority of students are still lagging badly.

“I don’t shy away from accountability,” Melander said. “Where I use it to my advantage is I turn it right back around. I will not let people forget what I am trying to accomplish in this building. I believe strongly that if you want something different, you have to do something drastic.”


Alejandra Matos • 612-673-4028


  • related content

  • Aug.: State test scores show achievement gap persists

    Wednesday October 1, 2014

    Minnesota students showed little overall improvement in reading, math or science, according to the latest batch of results from statewide, standardized tests taken by nearly 500,000 elementary and high school...

  • New office aims to zap the gap in Minneapolis public schools

    Thursday August 28, 2014

    Director of new office takes to the streets in his high-profile challenge to elevate the achievement of black males.

  • Aug.: State test scores show achievement gap persists

    Wednesday October 1, 2014

    Minnesota students showed little overall improvement in reading, math or science, according to the latest batch of results from statewide, standardized tests taken by nearly 500,000 elementary and high school...

  • Fifth-graders at Lucy Laney Community School have had a boost in math test scores from having two teachers. On Thursday, fifth-grade teachers Brittney Bentley, front, and Nicole Plowman, rear, prepared their students for a multiplication exercise using the game Yahtzee.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters






question of the day

Poll: What chance does the Wild have of making the playoffs?

Weekly Question