Minneapolis restaurants are ready to get rid of foam containers


William Murphy squeezed some sour cream on a slice of taco pizza to go that came in a foam container at Mesa Pizza in Minneapolis. The containers will be banned by next spring.

Photo: RENÉE JONES SCHNEIDER • reneejones@startribune.com,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Foam containers in restaurants are going the way of incandescent light bulbs: They can still be found, but their once ubiquitous presence is quickly fading.

Many Twin Cities eateries have chucked the white stuff in favor of newer, eco-friendly products. So as the city of Minneapolis joins dozens of U.S. cities in renewing its ban on polystyrene foam, often called Styrofoam, a lot of restaurant owners and managers say they are already prepared or are looking into greener options to meet next year’s deadline.

“I have not had a call from any restaurant saying, ‘We can’t do it,’ ” said Dan McElroy, executive vice president of the Minnesota Restaurant Association. “Not all restaurants have prepared for the changes, but we have enough time.”

The ordinance, part of a goal to be a zero-waste city, will go into effect in April 2015 and is a revision to a 25-year-old rule banning difficult-to-recycle materials. The guidelines mandate that restaurants, food trucks, grocery stores and event vendors only offer food in products that are easily recyclable, compostable or reusable.

The Brothers Deli in the downtown skyway saw the change coming and wanted to be greener, so it recently switched to baskets with tissue for dine-in orders. But owner Jeff Burstein isn’t quite sure what he will use to replace the 1,000 polystyrene takeout containers the deli uses in a week, and predicts he may have to raise prices 25 cents per entree to offer other options.

“The alternatives are triple the cost of Styrofoam,” he said, adding that despite its economic advantages, foam “isn’t very appealing.”

Coping with cost

Restaurants complain of a number of drawbacks to polystyrene foam, including that it doesn’t prevent spills and usually doesn’t vent well, leaving food soggy. And environmentalists have assailed it for years because it is not easily biodegradable.

On the other hand, proponents note that it’s a good insulator and is a cheaper way to go for mom-and-pop shops.

Indeed, cost is the main reason many restaurants still go with foam. Smaller, quick-serve places typically operate on thin margins and don’t want to pay extra for plastic and paper-based options.

Such eateries say the change will force them to raise menu prices as they switch to greener alternatives. Or they may tack on a small service charge on takeout orders. Others say they will absorb the price increase.

Keys Cafe & Bakery in downtown Minneapolis has been experimenting with paper alternatives for the 500 polystyrene takeout boxes it goes through in a week. Joe Schlarbaum, the general manager, said the substitutes are “strong and nice” but more expensive, so he’s still contemplating how to cope with the higher prices.

“We’re not sure that we want to go down the road of tacking on a surcharge for takeout,” he said, adding that an overall menu price increase is more likely.

Mesa Pizza Dinkytown doesn’t generally use foam containers except for single to-go slices. But manager Nato Coles said the business is not worried about having to find something else to replace it.

“Everybody at Mesa is solidly behind a citywide ban on Styrofoam containers because it puts nobody at a competitive disadvantage and does good for the environment,” he said.

City Council Member Andrew Johnson, who sponsored the measure, said many restaurants are already complying with the decades-old policy. He noted that other cities with bans haven’t been met with opposition from restaurants claiming financial hardship.

Most costs for restaurants come from labor, facilities, equipment and food, Johnson said. Food packaging might account for 1 or 2 percent, he said.

And while restaurants have been curtailing their use of foam, Johnson said there still are as many as 10 million polystyrene containers in Minneapolis’ waste system each year.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters






question of the day

Poll: How will the Wild-Chicago series turn out?

Weekly Question