Page 2 of 2 Previous

Continued: In Minnesota, abuse lawsuits die with the victims

  • Article by: BRANDON STAHL , Star Tribune
  • Last update: January 20, 2014 - 9:34 AM

The law requiring dismissal of injury cases after a person dies has its origins in English common law and has been effect in Minnesota since at least 1849. Most other states had similar laws until the 19th century, when legislatures began enacting exceptions because the standard was considered too harsh, according to a 1982 Minnesota Supreme Court ruling.

The ruling found part of the Survival Law unconstitutional and struck a provision that applied to lawsuit defendants who are perpetrators of harm. The law has been unchanged since then.

It’s unknown how often cases are dropped due to the Survival Law. When Minneapolis personal injury attorney Jim Carey first took on the case for the Albert Lea victims in 2010, he said he didn’t know about the law.

“This was one of the most tragic things in my career watching those cases get dismissed,” he said. “We’re talking about World War II heroes, schoolteachers, All-American good citizens.”

An analysis of the legislative proposal by the Minnesota Management and Budget Department estimated that if the bill passed, it would result in two more personal injury cases a year.

Smith said it would probably be far more than that. His firm, which specializes in elder abuse, typically turns down dozens of cases a year due to the risk that the clients will die before their claims are resolved in court, he said.

“If there’s a risk the client will die, in our legal system, that often means we can’t afford to take the case,” Smith said.

His firm researched Survival Laws in other states and found that only in Minnesota, Colorado, Idaho and Indiana do injury claims die with the plaintiff. That statistic was presented to the Minnesota Senate last year, which approved a version of the bill 57-4 and sent it to the House.

Kulda of the Insurance Federation acknowledged that the majority of states allow injury lawsuits to continue after the plaintiff’s death but said those states have caps on damages. Minnesota’s bill didn’t include that.

‘We tried, Mom’

The House made changes to the bill that exempted nursing homes from the law and would have increased how much families could seek in wrongful-death suits. The bill was sent back to the Senate, where the changes made by the House were met with surprise by both Republicans and Democrats.

“This is a major change in liability and it’s going to affect your insurance rates,” Sen. James Metzen, DFL-South St. Paul, said before the Senate vote.

An author of the Senate bill, Sen. Ron Latz, DFL-St. Louis Park, said he expects the legislation to be taken up again in the upcoming session.

Even if the bill passes, it would not be retroactive, leaving out families of the Albert Lea victims. Sorenson said that after the lawsuit was dismissed, she visited her mother’s grave to say she was sorry for letting her down.

“I said, ‘We tried, Mom.’ ”


Brandon Stahl • 612-673-4626


  • related content

  • Video: In Minnesota, abuse lawsuits die with the victims

    Sunday January 19, 2014

    The sexual and physical assaults of 15 residents in an Albert Lea nursing home in 2008 outraged Minnesotans, led...

  • Special report: When nurses fail

    Friday May 16, 2014

    The Star Tribune is examining Minnesota’s oversight of nurses who violate standards of care and conduct. Over the past six months, the newspaper has analyzed thousands of records and interviewed...

  • Robin Grunhovd talked about the abuse suffered by her father. State lawmakers soon may consider changing what’s known as Minnesota’s Survival Law, which requires that a personal injury case be dropped if the victim dies of unrelated causes.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters






question of the day

Poll: How will the Wild-Chicago series turn out?

Weekly Question