Sister of Dru Sjodin's killer says he needs mental health help, not a death sentence

Last update: October 22, 2007 - 7:14 PM

FARGO, N.D. -- The sister of the man convicted of kidnapping and killing college student Dru Sjodin says her brother needs mental health treatment, not death by lethal injection.

Ileanna Noyes spoke Sunday at North Dakota State University in a panel discussion sponsored by the North Dakota Human Rights Coalition, which opposes the death penalty.

Noyes is the sister of Alfonso Rodriguez Jr., who was convicted and sentenced to death by federal jurors in Fargo for the kidnapping and killing of Sjodin, 22, a University of North Dakota student from Pequot Lakes, Minn.

Noyes said a juror approached her after Sunday's talk and said he regretted his decision. "He said it's been eating at him," Noyes said. "I told him I didn't hold any grudges against him."

Sjodin's family recently reached a $300,000 settlement with the state of Minnesota over claims that state authorities were partly responsible for Sjodin's death by releasing Rodriguez, a convicted rapist, after he finished serving a 23-year sentence for stabbing and trying to abduct a woman.

A state psychologist had decided against recommending Rodriguez for civil commitment.

Noyes said she made phone calls to try to keep her brother in prison or in a treatment program.

After her brother's arrest, Noyes said, she tried to help police and the Sjodin family. She recorded a conversation with Rodriguez in jail to try to help authorities. Her husband, Dan, joined the search party to look for Sjodin. She said her family has received death threats and has needed authorities to keep watch at their home in Crookston, Minn.

Noyes said her family supports punishment for her brother's crime, but she believes that the death penalty is cruel and racially motivated and that it tortures the defendant's family. "I see him as an ill man who needs mental health care, not a lethal injection," she said of her brother.

ASSOCIATED PRESS

Recent Local + Metro stories

Minn. man, 98, dies; his brother, 95, hospitalized - October 22, 2007

Minn. man, 98, dies; his brother, 95, hospitalized - A 95-year-old man from northwestern Minnesota is hospitalized after he went out looking for his older brother who had wandered off. More