The pants still fit, but maturity eludes the sisterhood in this flimsy drama.
It's been three summers since we first met the foursome of friends in the film version of "The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants." The sequel finds the girls a bit older, now in college. But sadly, they're no wiser -- in fact, they seem to have regressed.
Based on Ann Brashares' series of young-adult books, the story is bound by a pair of jeans that mysteriously fit all four friends -- we're told, but never shown, that they even flatter the zaftig Carmen (America Ferrera). As in the original film, the girls keep in touch throughout their respective summer adventures by mailing the supposedly magical pants to each other. Also, the drama continues to revolve around the friends' inability to talk about their problems.
However, unlike the sparkly first film (directed by Ken Kwapis), this version (by Sanaa Hamri, better known for making music videos) socks the young women with a series of problems that may leave viewers scratching their heads.
The film certainly looks contemporary -- characters come readily equipped with cell phones and some of the friends indulge in the au courant practice of interracial dating. Why, then, doesn't Tibby (Amber Tamblyn), by now a funky, seemingly street-smart film student at NYU, seek emergency contraception the moment her boyfriend's condom breaks? And what's the deal with Carmen's disdain for e-mail?
The first installment was as watchable as any warm-hearted teen drama: Carmen was reunited with her deadbeat dad while Tibby befriended a spunky 12-year-old dying of leukemia. But the only meat to this second helping involves Bridget ("Gossip Girl" superstar Blake Lively), who continues to wrestle with her mother's suicide. Other than this, the sequel coasts on flimsy and/or benign narratives that involve postponed adulthood, cute boys who speak with deadened, unvarying inflections and ignorance of modern conveniences. All the while, a cloying musical score tries to enlist the empathy of viewers who should know better.
Members of the sisterhood are often getting upset for one baffling reason or another. Ferrera's jittery character in particular -- in this film she's cast as Perdita in a summer-stock production of "The Winter's Tale" -- makes mountains out of molehills. She's not likable whatsoever. After an hour or so of watching her moan, pout and otherwise get irritated by trivial matters (including the fact that her best girlfriends lack ESP), the viewer might rather stick pins in her eyes than feel affection for such a tedious, self-pitying young woman.
Christy DeSmith is a Minneapolis freelance writer.