Fear of falling on ice is physical and mental problem

  • Article by: BILL WARD , Star Tribune
  • Updated: January 25, 2014 - 9:52 PM

After a fall on the ice, recovery involves healing bruises to our bodies — and our psyches.


Trying not to fall becomes a winter obsession.

Photo: Associated Press,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

It’s been a rough few months for Pat Robinson Schmidt.

Although she doesn’t consider herself “a slip-and-fall person,” Schmidt already has tumbled twice on the ice, including when she was on the way to buy nonslip shoes.

“I wouldn’t say I’m terrified, but I’m always worried,” said Schmidt, 59, of St. Louis Park.

That’s understandable.

Over a five-year period ending in June, 89 percent of claims filed with the state for outdoor falls came between October and April. Nationally, falls are one of the leading causes of injuries treated in emergency rooms, according to the National Safety Council, with almost 9 million in 2012.

A winter such as this only makes things worse. After starting with an early-December storm that deposited an icy base, the season’s treacherous thaw-and-refreeze cycle only promises to continue.

Falling is one thing. Recovering from the psychological effects is every bit as slippery.

Being wary of ice is “a healthy adaptive response,” said Kent Smallwood, senior clinical psychologist at Hennepin County Medical Center. “I want to be scared if a grizzly bear is running at me, just as I want to be scared when I’m walking on slippery ice.”

But sometimes, he added, that fear can overwhelm us, making us afraid to go outside, keeping us virtual prisoners in our homes until snowmelt.

It’s important to “have a realistic appraisal of danger,” said Chris Vye, chair of the University of St. Thomas’ graduate school of professional psychology. After a tumble, worried walkers need to “return to a state where they are comfortable facing the risks that come with daily life,” said Vye.

Pride goes with the fall

Don Darling, owner of Physical Therapy Orthopedic Specialist Inc., said he frequently has to repair brains as well as bones.

“If they’ve slipped and fallen one time, they are so nervous,” Darling said. “It almost sets them up for another injury, because they’re not relaxed, they’re stiff. Or they just won’t go outside.”

In many cases, that’s because the fall also wounded their pride.

Tracy Fausone-Hartjen 36, of Vadnais Heights has multiple sclerosis, but her apprehension “is more emotional than physical,” especially after she tumbled into a parked vehicle outside her daughter’s dance school last year.

“It was devastating to my daughter and embarrassing for me,” said the mother of two. “Now falling on ice terrifies me. … When it gets extremely cold, snowy and/or icy, I stay home and my mother takes the kids to their activities. But if there’s somewhere I have to go, I still go, like a dance performance for my daughter or a choir concert.”

This dread seems to grow as we age. Our sense of balance starts slipping in our 20s, and can be quite shaky by the time we reach our “golden years.”

“Older people have underlying balance problems and vision problems so they don’t see the ice,” said Dr. Jacqueline Geissler, an orthopedic and hand surgeon at Hennepin County Medical Center. “Also, as we age we tend to have less bone in our bone, so we’re more at risk. All the bones are at risk.”

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


question of the day

Poll: What's your favorite cream pie?

Weekly Question





Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters