Gas, electric, hybrid -- which is best for you?

  • Article by: NANCY CROTTI , Special to the Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 8, 2012 - 9:50 AM

University of Minnesota professor develops an online tool to help you decide which one is best for you.

hide

The 2010 Nissan Leaf.

Photo: Allen J. Schaben, Mct

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

When Douglas Tiffany's grandfather emigrated from England around 1910, he used his woodworking skills to make models of cars that would be built in Detroit.

A century later, Tiffany is working with cars, too -- but in a distinctly updated medium.

Tiffany, an assistant extension professor at the University of Minnesota Twin Cities campuses, has developed an online spreadsheet tool that allows car buyers to figure out what kind of vehicle would be best for them -- conventional, hybrid or electric.

The spreadsheet -- which can be downloaded at Bit.ly/u970at -- allows buyers to compare conventional vehicles to hybrids such as the Toyota Prius, electric vehicles such as the Nissan Leaf, and extended-range electric vehicles such as the Chevrolet Volt. A short video on the site shows you how to use the spreadsheet. If you want to know even more, you can watch an hour-long video of a lecture Tiffany delivered on the subject.

The spreadsheet makes certain assumptions, such as the price of a particular type of vehicle, the interest rate charged on a car loan, and the expected miles per gallon of gas or kilowatt hour, and calculates the costs and carbon footprint over 15 years.

Car shoppers can insert figures such as the number of miles they drive per year to determine if a conventional, hybrid or electric car is the best value for them or will reduce their carbon footprint.

An agricultural energy researcher, Tiffany started the car-comparison project a couple of years ago when his brother mentioned he was considering buying a hybrid. "I said, 'Well, I think I can work out a good way to make this comparison,' " Tiffany said.

The federal Environmental Protection Agency has a comparison model that ranks mileage of hybrid versus conventional cars, but Tiffany wanted to take it further. His first version of the spreadsheet compared conventional cars with hybrids, taking into account a driver's estimated annual mileage. His second version provides more information, such as the carbon footprint made by the electricity that is generated to power electric cars versus that made by gasoline emissions. (The spreadsheet includes the average price of residential electricity consumed in Minnesota, but drivers can input figures for states that rely more or less on coal for electricity production and come with a lower carbon footprint.)

"I could imagine a household where one member says, 'We really have to do something different. We really have to reduce our carbon footprint,' and another member says, 'Can we afford it?' " Tiffany said. "I was able to bring those two things together and quantify them."

The web site has generated 4,300 visits since November. Shortly after it went up, an Chevrolet dealership in Indiana commented on how well it identified aspects of the Volt, according to Tiffany.

Tiffany's brother eventually bought a conventional car because it made the most sense for his type of driving. Some audience members at Tiffany's lectures who had been enthusiastic about buying a hybrid or electric car were disappointed to learn it didn't make economic sense.

Tiffany, who drives a 1998 Subaru Legacy, is keeping his options open.

"I calculate what sort of a carbon tax you are charging yourself by driving one of these vehicles," Tiffany said. "As an overall statement, I'd say we're really moving into an exciting time. The hybrids have come of age. They're known as reliable vehicles that do what they're supposed to and really have very few problems. They've kind of moved into the mainstream, and there will be many more types of hybrids and there will be many more electric vehicles coming out, too."

Like anyone who's interested in cars, Tiffany continues to work on his model. "I kind of want to keep tinkering and making it better," he said.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Which top 2014 restaurant do you most want to try?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close