How I saved too much for retirement
Posted on May 19th, 2008 – 2:13 PMBy Kara McGuire
I try to max out a Roth IRA each year. I like this type of account, which I’ve referred to as the little black dress of personal finance, because of its versatility. It’s designed for retirement, but since it’s an after-tax account, you can take your contributions out tax free at any time. That makes it a great save for emergencies, save for a big ticket item account.
Although, of course, if you have all of your money in aggressive stock funds, you could risk losing some of your principal and not having it available if you need it. So I have another smaller emergency savings account too.
Anyway, this weekend I received a statement for my 2007 contributions to my IRA. In 2007, you could contribute $4,000; this year it’s $5,000. You can contribute to an IRA for the prior year through tax day– aka April 15th. So my monthly contributions in January through March actually went towards my 2007 limit. Confused, yet?
So the statement said that I saved $4,000.95 for tax year 2007. But the max is $4,000. How annoying is that? I blame it on my mid-year attempt to save exactly $4,000 through dollar cost averaging. Clearly, I goofed on my math, which is no surprise since I often make tweaks to my finances at night when everyone else is asleep and I have the time, but not always the brain power.
I called A.B.C. mutual fund company and told them of my situation. The woman said she couldn’t tell me to do nothing on the recorded line, but that she’s never heard of the IRS flagging a return because a person saved .95 cents too much in a tax advantaged account.
If I wanted to, she would send out an excess contributions form, which would guide me through the calculations to determine how much I earned on that .95 cents and what penalty or taxes I would owe. That sounds time consuming on several levels.
With the contribution limits for IRAs indexed to inflation going forward, I hope that A.B.C and other fund companies that undoubtedly have thousands of customers who wish to max out their IRAs by automatically socking away a sum each month will streamline this process. Anyone know a company that does make this easy?
For those of you who want the whole excess contributions enchilada, here’s IRS Pub 590 .
