Page 2 of 2 Previous

Continued: Ruling stands: Brainerd woman must pay $222,000 for illegal music downloads

  • Article by: DAN BROWNING , Star Tribune
  • Last update: March 18, 2013 - 8:32 PM

The fact that the Supreme Court declined to resolve that issue can be seen as kind of victory for the defense lawyers who’ve spent untold hours and money representing Thomas-Rasset at no charge, said Kenneth Port, director of the Intellectual Property Institute at William Mitchell College of Law. “They are the heroes in this case,” he said.

Unfortunately, Port said, it remains unresolved whether active distribution is required for a copyright violation to occur. Port, who wrote a friend-of-the-court brief in the case, said the plain language of the statute does not equate “distribution” with making a protected work available to others. Congress has amended the law a number of times but has failed to change that, he said.

Issue could resurface

Kiwi Camara, a Houston intellectual property lawyer who represented Thomas-Rasset in the appeal to the Supreme Court, said in an e-mail that its refusal to hear arguments in the case was disappointing. He said the issue could return to the court in the case of Joel Tenenbaum, which is currently pending in the First Circuit. Tenenbaum faces a judgment of $675,000 for 31 songs he distributed while a student at Boston University.

Thomas-Rasset said she hasn’t been thinking much about her case. She said she has more important considerations, like the arrival of her first grandson, Cole, nine months ago. “He’s a hoot!” she said.

Dan Browning • 612-673-4493

  • related content

  • Jammie Thomas-Rasset in her lawyers office with l to r in the backgro...

  • Thomas-Rasset

  • The kazaa chronology

    Oct. 2, 2007: Jammie Thomas becomes first to go to court to fight charges of illegally sharing music files.

    Oct. 4, 2007: Jury fines her $222,000, or $9,250 each for 24 songs.

    September 2008: Chief U.S. District Judge Michael Davis orders new trial.

    June 2009: Jury fines Jammie, now Thomas-Rasset, $1.9 million, or $80,000 per song.

    January 2010: Davis slashes damages to $54,000, or $2,250 per song. Music industry refuses award.

    November 2010: Third jury imposes $1.5 million fine.

    August 2011: Thomas-Rasset appeals.

    September 2012: U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals orders Davis to reinstate the $222,000 award.

    March 18, 2013: U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear case.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters