StarTribune.com
willie071808

On the homepage

 
Holiday Entertainment
Guthrie's A Christmas Carol

Guthrie's A Christmas Carol

Celebrating 35 years of a Twin Cities' holiday tradition!
Chanhassen Dinner Theatre

Chanhassen Dinner Theatre

$15 Gift For You With Every $100 Gift Certificate Purchased!
VocalEssence

VocalEssence

"The best choral show of the season" (Mpls.St.Paul) on Dec 6, 11, 12 & 13
Children's Theatre Co.

Children's Theatre Co.

Cinderella Nov. 10 - Jan. 2
All Is Calm

All Is Calm

"Gorgeously moving." 6 Performances Only! Dec. 17-20 - Pantages 800.982.2787
Actors Theatre Of Minnesota

Actors Theatre Of Minnesota

Holiday Savings 25-50% off tickets
Triple Espresso

Triple Espresso

Set Your Funny Free! Nov 19 - Jan 10 Kids Tickets 1/2 price
Plymouth Playhouse

Plymouth Playhouse

Our gift certificates make great holiday presents! Come and see:

Home | Entertainment

Why Willie, not Neil, should be at the X

Last update: July 17, 2008 - 4:21 PM

Selling out Grand Casino Hinckley's 5,700-seat amphitheater in a matter of days is no small feat. But compared with Neil Diamond, who has almost sold out two nights at St. Paul's Xcel Energy Center, Willie Nelson might be seen as the second-biggest American music icon performing in Minnesota this weekend.

But anyone who believes that must be smoking some of Willie's favorite herb. The country legend turned 75 in April and shows no signs of slowing down, with at least three new albums over the past year compared with the three that Diamond has put out in the past decade. Here are five more reasons for Neil fans to give it up for Willie:

1 Two names: Patsy Cline and the Monkees. Both Willie and Neil made it as songwriters early in their careers, and their biggest hits were for a legend and a punch line, respectively: Cline with Willie's "Crazy," the Pre-Fab Four with Neil's "I'm a Believer." To be fair, there are no Willie songs in "Shrek."

2 Two more names: Snoop Dogg and Wynton Marsalis. Those are the latest in a long line of unlikely collaborators who've recorded with Willie. He sings on Snoop's "My Medicine" and just issued a charming live album with Marsalis, "Two Men With the Blues." OK, so Neil also has an interesting pairing with Natalie Maines on his new record. But the Texas chick would shine Willie's boots -- or, rather, wash his New Balance sneakers -- if he asked.

3Tale of two TV tapings. This spring Neil made a much-ballyhooed appearance on "American Idol" to (what else?) promote his new CD. This fall Willie will once again make a mostly ignored appearance on his umpteenth televised Farm Aid concert (Sept. 20 near Boston, details to be announced) to promote the plight of noncorporate American farms. His Family Farm Disaster Fund has already distributed $40,000 to flood-affected Midwest farmers this summer.

4By the numbers. Grammy Awards: eight for Willie, one for Neil. Singles on the Billboard charts: 119 for Willie, 105 for Neil. Total albums (excluding hits packages): 107 for Willie, 39 for Neil (per Allmusic.com). Never mind who's sold more.

5Loose is better in concert. Both singers could better vary their set lists. However, amid the predictable tunes, Willie is often unpredictable, changing up the tempo of one song or completely improvising through another. Neil wouldn't know improvisation if it bit him on his hair plugs.

Chris Riemenschneider • 612-673-4658

Recent Entertainment stories

Cameo critic: Nick Urata - July 17, 2008
Cameo critic: Nick Urata - Denver's DeVotchka is known for its gypsy-tinged, polyethnic rock eclecticism. More

Comment on this story   |   Read all 3 comments   |  Hide reader comments

Subscribe
Entertainment Finder
Shopping + Classifieds
Find A Job

Open positions!

A new career awaits. Look through thousands of listings to find your new job. Start now!
Yellow Pages

Get A Professional

Find home maintenance, car repair, legal advice, cleaning, and more in the Yellow Pages. Go now!