BNSF cited for serious flaws in track before N.D. accident

  • Article by: DAVID SHAFFER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: February 20, 2014 - 9:36 AM

The Federal Railroad Administration, in response to a request from a North Dakota senator, says its inspections frequently turned up defective track.


A BNSF Railway train hauled crude oil near Wolf Point, Mont. Potentially explosive shipments have increased 40-fold in recent years as crude production boomed.

Photo: Matthew Brown • Associated Press file,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Federal rail inspectors have cited BNSF Railway Co. in North Dakota for 721 track violations, finding problems serious enough to threaten fines in one out of every five inspections since 2006, according to federal data released Wednesday.

Federal Railroad Administrator Joseph Szabo said in a letter to a North Dakota senator that federal officials conducted 3,822 inspections during the period and found 13,141 defects, the vast majority of which were addressed without fines.

However, in 721 instances, or 19 percent of the inspections, officials determined that BNSF violated railroad regulations. That happens when a problem isn’t fixed or is serious enough to warrant a violation right away. Szabo’s letter, released by Sen. Heidi Heitkamp, D-N.D., didn’t describe the violations, the track conditions that produced them or say how much BNSF paid in fines.

Heitkamp asked for the information after a BNSF oil train crashed a mile outside Casselton, N.D., on Dec. 30, producing explosions, a massive fire and temporary evacuation of much of the town, though no one was hurt. It was one of approximately 10 oil trains that depart daily from the Bakken oil fields, most of which run on BNSF tracks that lead into Minnesota.

In the letter, Szabo said the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) has an ongoing investigation and safety assessment of the BNSF rail line in Cass County, where the accident occurred. He said four derailments have occurred on the line over nine years, two of which were track-related — a misalignment near Casselton in 2005 and a broken rail near Page, N.D., in 2008. The others, he said were equipment-related.

But Szabo’s letter offered no comparison of BNSF’s North Dakota problems to those of other railroads. FRA annual enforcement reports also don’t offer comparable track-related violations, and an agency spokesman was unable to provide the information Wednesday. In 2013, BNSF was assessed $2.3 million in fines across the nation, according to the FRA’s report.

BNSF, which responded to the letter and reporters’ questions by e-mail Wednesday, said derailments on mainlines hit record lows last year, and that busy routes are inspected twice as frequently as the FRA requires. In North Dakota last year, the company said, it replaced 415,000 ties and 300 miles of rail and will make a record investment this year to maintain and expand capacity in the state.

BNSF spokeswoman Amy McBeth said defects detected by FRA and BNSF can include ties, rail anchors, the rock ballast around ties, switches, loose bolts and cracked bars. Many problems are immediately repaired or speed restrictions are imposed until repairs are made, she said. FRA audits over the past seven years found less than one defect per mile on BNSF’s 2,300 miles of North Dakota track, she added.

Heitkamp said it’s clear that the Casselton area, 20 miles west of Fargo, needs increased attention considering the number of derailments there.

“Folks who live near these tracks have been through a lot, and deserve to know that the rails are under close examination and that FRA is doing everything to make sure North Dakotans aren’t at risk,” she said in a statement.

The National Transportation Safety Board is investigating the Dec. 30 accident, but has not determined the cause. A broken axle was found near the crash, which happened after a westbound soybean train derailed on a parallel track. The oil train, which was headed for Minnesota, crashed into a grain car that had landed on the eastbound track.

Inspection vehicle

In July, the letter said, the FRA ran an automated track inspection vehicle from Dilworth, Minn., to Mandan, N.D., and discovered 11 problems over 202 miles. Another such inspection is planned later this year, the letter added.

Larry Mann, a rail safety attorney based in Washington, D.C., said in an interview that FRA’s disclosure that it conducted just one automated inspection on the BNSF line in 2013, with one planned in 2014, illustrates the weakness in federal oversight.

“They should do it frequently,” Mann said of the automated inspections, which examine whether tracks’ distance apart, alignment and other parameters meet specifications. “That is what causes derailments.”

Mann also said that violations carry such low penalties that they don’t serve as deterrents.

Heitkamp and others in Congress and in the Minnesota Legislature have called for hearings on rail safety in light of recent oil train accidents.

Trains with 100 or more tank cars carry away about 70 percent of North Dakota’s nearly 1 million barrels of daily crude oil production. Most oil trains go through Minnesota, with six a day, on average, passing through the Twin Cities, according to the Minnesota Department of Transportation.

  • related content

  • Minnesota fire crews 'ill-prepared' for any oil train catastrophe

    Tuesday February 11, 2014

    Six trains with 100 or more crude oil tank cars pass through the Twin Cities every day, and if one of them wrecks, state and local emergency responders don’t have...

  • Dec. 31: Casselton residents flee after oil train explosion

    Tuesday December 31, 2013

    A crew from Little Rock, Ark., endured subzero temperatures overnight to check for any health hazards. "Right now, we're in limbo," a deputy sheriff told the Star Tribune.

  • Jan. 23: NTSB urges oil trains be rerouted to avoid cities

    Thursday January 23, 2014

    The recommendation would be extremely difficult to implement, industry and civic leaders say.

  • Minnesota legislators push for better oil-transport disaster response

    Wednesday February 12, 2014

    As more crude oil passes through Minnesota on trains and pipelines, state legislators say emergency responders need more training and equipment to respond to accidents.

  • A year in North Dakota: Stories of people and change

    Tuesday January 7, 2014

    Behind the oil industry's gaudy numbers, you’ll find countless dreamers, schemers and in between.

  • Mayor Ed McConnell of Casselton, N.D., walked amid the wreckage nearly three weeks after oil-train explosions and fires forced most of the city’s 2,400 residents to evacuate the town on New Year’s Eve.

  • Robert Sumwalt, right, of the National Transportation Safety Board stood amid the wreckage two days after an oil train struck a derailed grain car a mile west of Casselton, N.D., on Dec. 30.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions





Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters