RECALLBIZ111107.BAR
On the homepage
Vikings
Out There
Pardon Board
Petters
When E. coli strikes, who pays?
Print this story
E-mail this story
Save to del.icio.us
Share on Facebook
Share on Digg
Minnesota business by the numbers
See Minnesota's top earning companies, CEOs and non-profits
Related Content
More from Business
If a person gets sick eating a company's hamburger, should the company pay the medical bills? And how quickly?
William Marler, a lawyer who has made a career representing E. coli victims, says businesses should be proactive. His latest client is a 4-year-old boy who was sickened last month after eating a hamburger made with meat that came from a Cargill processing plant. The boy, John McDonald, lost part of his intestine, suffered kidney failure and was hospitalized for nearly a month. His year-old sister was also hospitalized for a week with the same strain of E. coli.
Marler says Cargill has refused to pay the McDonalds' medical bills and filed a lawsuit this week seeking unspecified damages.
Meanwhile, Stephanie Smith, 20, from Cold Spring, Minn., who was sickened in the same outbreak, remains in a drug-induced coma at the Mayo Clinic, where doctors are trying to save her life. Her family believes that she was sickened after eating ground beef the weekend of Sept. 22.
It was the second ground beef recall this year for Cargill Meat Solutions Corp., a subsidiary of the Minnetonka-based agribusiness giant, which posted net income of $917 million in its most recent quarter.
A spokeswoman for Cargill said the company does not comment concerning pending litigation.
And while there's no law that specifically directs a food company to pay medical bills in cases such as these, it's clear from past court decisions that E. coli cases can quickly spiral out of control for meatpackers, one observer said.
"They can face very big liability," said Alfred Marcus, a professor at the Carlson School of Management at the University of Minnesota. "The question becomes -- as cruel as this might sound -- what's an intestine worth?"
Marler said that past outbreaks linked to the Odwalla Juice Co. and to the Jack-in-the-Box hamburger chain saw both companies make early payments for victims' medical bills.
A company might try arguing that the consumer should have cooked the hamburger longer, but it's not usually a wise argument, another observer said.
"That gets to be a delicate argument, because in one sense, you are trying to blame the victims," said Ralph Hall, a professor at the University of Minnesota Law School.
Matt McKinney • 612-673-7329
Matt McKinney • mckinney@startribune.com
Recent Business stories
More consumers make credit card payments on time in 3Q, pay off debt in summer months - November 10, 2007
More consumers make credit card payments on time in 3Q, pay off debt in summer months - Consumers got more serious about paying down their credit card debt this summer, a time when deliquencies usually go up. More
- Holiday gift: Amazon-Wal-Mart price war
- Record 2.1M dropside cribs recalled
- Verdict? Petters jurors back at it today
- Economy's rebound not as strong as first thought
- A man with a plan to get jobless working stiffs back to work
- Stores jump the gun to get jump on competition
- Medtronic reports higher second-quarter earnings
Blog: Patent Pending
Lights out at U energy conference. Irony police notified.
Just as Lawrence Kazmerski, a top official at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, was about to give the keynote address at the University of Minnesota's annual E3 conference at the RiverCentre in St. Paul, the lights went out, bathing the audience in darkness and a deep sense of irony.
Comment on this story | Be the first to comment | Hide reader comments