autos
Extended warranties: Value is a matter of personal choice
- Article by: PAUL BRAND
- Updated: November 2, 2012 - 4:02 PM
- 0
- comments
resize text 
- buy reprints
Q I would like to comment on your recent column on whether it is worthwhile to buy an extended warranty for a car. Extended warranties are provided by companies that need to earn a profit. In order to do this, they have to collect more money from their customers than they pay out. It is possible for a car owner to benefit from buying an extended warranty, but most people pay out more than they get back. Otherwise, the company providing the warranty won't stay in business. When I buy a car, computer or home appliance, I always decline the extended warranty. If something breaks after the warranty period, I pay for the repair with money I've saved by not buying any extended warranties, and I come out ahead. With regard to deductibles, I used to pay for low deductibles on car and house insurance. After a while I realized this was not the best option and I switched to higher deductibles. If I have to make an insurance claim, I will pay the higher deductible with money I save on insurance premiums, and I come out ahead. The same principle applies to the deductible on an extended warranty, which is another form of insurance.
A I received a number of letters and e-mails commenting on my column regarding my change in position on extended warranties and service contracts. It described how now, after nearly 30 years as a "car guy," I believe in the value of purchasing an extended warranty or service contract on a new or late-model vehicle that you're going to keep for long beyond the original manufacturer's warranty expires.
I agree with the above car owner in terms of extended warranties and service contracts on appliances, home electronics and other relatively low-cost purchases. But with modern vehicles costing hundreds, even thousands of dollars to repair, I disagree.
I certainly respect the position but want to point out that, while liability coverage, and in some states personal injury protection, is mandated by law, insurance for your own vehicle is not. Thus, choosing collision and comprehensive coverage is very much akin to purchasing an extended warranty or service contract.
I choose to carry collision and comprehensive coverage on my newer vehicles. With repair and replacement costs potentially in the tens of thousands of dollars, I can't see operating them with no coverage for a loss from a crash, fire, theft or vandalism.
Ditto health insurance. It's difficult to imagine the consequences of having no coverage for a significant health issue.
I feel the same way about potential mechanical and electronic failures. Labor and replacement parts for major repairs can easily run into the hundreds or thousands of dollars. Most of us worry about engine or transmission failures as a major expense, but systems such as climate control, electronic steering, anti-lock braking system and traction control, and other sophisticated systems can cost just as much to repair or replace.
The question of deductibles is valid. I, too, carry high deductibles for collision and comprehensive coverage (and health insurance) for the basic reason that I don't expect to make claims very often. But I recognize that repairs from mechanical and electronic failures, and wear and tear over the 10-plus years I keep my vehicles, are virtually inevitable. Thus, I want to continue protection for the time/mileage frame beyond the original carmaker's warranty.
I prefer zero or very low deductibles for extended warranties and service contracts because unlike collision or comprehensive claims, which tend to deal with a single large-loss event, mechanical and electronic breakages, failures or problems can occur a number of times, particularly later in a vehicle's service life -- precisely the time and mileage framework covered by these warranties and contracts. I'd rather not have to pay $50 or $100 every time I take the vehicle in for even a minor problem.
As always, life is a matter of choices. In this case, you pay your money or you take your chances. There's no right or wrong answer. It's what you're comfortable with.
- 0
- comments
- resize text
- buy reprints
ADVERTISEMENT
| Cincinnati | 3:30 PM |
| Houston |
| Minnesota | 7:00 PM |
| Green Bay |
| Indianapolis | 1/6/13 12:00 PM |
| Baltimore |
| Seattle | 1/6/13 3:30 PM |
| Washington |
| Boston | 6:00 PM |
| Atlanta |
| Milwaukee | 6:00 PM |
| Indiana |
| New York | 6:00 PM |
| Orlando |
| Houston | 6:30 PM |
| Cleveland |
| Sacramento | 6:30 PM |
| Brooklyn |
| Portland | 7:00 PM |
| Minnesota |
| Philadelphia | 7:30 PM |
| San Antonio |
| New Orleans | 7:30 PM |
| Dallas |
| Utah | 8:00 PM |
| Denver |
| Golden State | 9:30 PM |
| LA Clippers |
| Pittsburgh | 25 | 2nd Half |
| Rutgers | 39 |
| Princeton | 11:00 AM |
| Elon |
| Purdue | 11:00 AM |
| Michigan State |
| Virginia Tech | 11:00 AM |
| Maryland |
| Wake Forest | 11:00 AM |
| Duke |
| Seton Hall | 11:00 AM |
| Notre Dame |
| UMBC | 11:00 AM |
| Maine |
| Delaware | 11:00 AM |
| Old Dominion |
| Hartford | 12:00 PM |
| Boston Univ |
| UNC-Wilmington | 12:00 PM |
| Northeastern |
| Oklahoma State | 12:30 PM |
| Kansas State |
| SC State | 12:30 PM |
| South Carolina |
| Bethune-Cookman | 12:30 PM |
| LSU |
| Green Bay | 1:00 PM |
| Detroit |
| High Point | 1:00 PM |
| Winthrop |
| Coastal Carolina | 1:00 PM |
| Longwood |
| Albany | 1:00 PM |
| Vermont |
| George Mason | 1:00 PM |
| William & Mary |
| Georgetown | 1:00 PM |
| Marquette |
| Eastern Mich | 1:00 PM |
| Massachusetts |
| James Madison | 1:00 PM |
| Georgia State |
| Texas | 1:00 PM |
| Baylor |
| Nebraska Omaha | 1:00 PM |
| IUPU-Ft Wayne |
| Penn | 1:00 PM |
| La Salle |
| Marshall | 1:00 PM |
| Ohio |
| New Hampshire | 1:00 PM |
| Stony Brook |
| New Orleans | 1:00 PM |
| Butler |
| Jacksonville | 1:00 PM |
| Fla Gulf Coast |
| Ohio State | 1:15 PM |
| Illinois |
| Mercer | 1:30 PM |
| Kennesaw St |
| Miami-Florida | 1:30 PM |
| Georgia Tech |
| Long Island | 2:00 PM |
| Quinnipiac |
| Stanford | 2:00 PM |
| UCLA |
| Columbia | 2:00 PM |
| Army |
| Fairfield | 2:00 PM |
| Niagara |
| Indiana State | 2:05 PM |
| Creighton |
| North Florida | 2:15 PM |
| Stetson |
| St Francis-NY | 2:30 PM |
| Sacred Heart |
| Gardner-Webb | 2:30 PM |
| Campbell |
| Char Southern | 3:00 PM |
| Radford |
| Oklahoma | 3:00 PM |
| West Virginia |
| Bryant | 3:00 PM |
| St Francis-PA |
| Fair-Dickinson | 3:00 PM |
| Wagner |
| Florida A&M | 3:00 PM |
| UCF |
| Florida State | 3:00 PM |
| Clemson |
| Bucknell | 3:00 PM |
| Missouri |
| Rice | 3:00 PM |
| Harvard |
| Youngstown St | 3:00 PM |
| Loyola-Chicago |
| Towson | 3:00 PM |
| Drexel |
| St Johns | 3:00 PM |
| Cincinnati |
| Saint Josephs | 3:00 PM |
| Morgan State |
| Howard | 3:00 PM |
| Coppin State |
| Lamar | 3:00 PM |
| Northwestern St |
| NC State | 3:00 PM |
| Boston College |
| Oakland | 3:00 PM |
| Alabama |
| Loyola Marymount | 3:30 PM |
| St Marys-CA |
| St Bonaventure | 3:30 PM |
| Colorado State |
| Central Arkansas | 4:00 PM |
| SE Louisiana |
| Utah | 4:00 PM |
| Arizona |
| Lehigh | 4:00 PM |
| VA Commonwealth |
| Navy | 4:00 PM |
| Norfolk State |
| Furman | 4:00 PM |
| Coll of Charleston |
| Oral Roberts | 4:00 PM |
| Nicholls |
| NC Wesleyan | 4:00 PM |
| East Carolina |
| Southern Utah | 4:05 PM |
| Northern Ariz |
| South Dakota St | 4:05 PM |
| South Dakota |
| Tennessee St | 4:30 PM |
| Jacksonville St |
| Texas Tech | 5:00 PM |
| TCU |
| Murray State | 5:00 PM |
| SE Missouri St |
| UNC-Asheville | 5:00 PM |
| Liberty |
| North Dakota St | 5:15 PM |
| UMKC |
| Austin Peay | 6:00 PM |
| Tenn-Martin |
| UAB | 6:00 PM |
| Dayton |
| USC Upstate | 6:00 PM |
| Northern Ky |
| Colgate | 6:00 PM |
| Dartmouth |
| NC A&T | 6:00 PM |
| Ga Southern |
| Central Conn St | 6:00 PM |
| Robert Morris |
| UNC Greensboro | 6:00 PM |
| Davidson |
| Marist | 6:00 PM |
| Canisius |
| McNeese State | 6:00 PM |
| Stephen F Austin |
| Monmouth | 6:00 PM |
| Mount St Marys |
| Long Beach State | 6:00 PM |
| UC Santa Barbara |
| Va Military | 6:00 PM |
| Presbyterian |
| Milwaukee | 6:00 PM |
| Wright State |
| SIU Edwardsville | 6:00 PM |
| Eastern Ky |
| Western Carolina | 6:05 PM |
| Citadel |
| Louisiana | 6:30 PM |
| FIU |
| East Tenn St | 6:30 PM |
| Lipscomb |
| Eastern Ill | 6:30 PM |
| Morehead State |
| Delaware State | 7:00 PM |
| Arkansas |
| DePaul | 7:00 PM |
| Providence |
| Gonzaga | 7:00 PM |
| Santa Clara |
| ULM | 7:00 PM |
| North Texas |
| Chattanooga | 7:00 PM |
| Samford |
| Louisiana Tech | 7:00 PM |
| Texas-Arlington |
| IUPUI | 7:00 PM |
| Western Ill |
| Middle Tennessee | 7:05 PM |
| South Alabama |
| Northern Iowa | 7:05 PM |
| Illinois State |
| Missouri State | 7:05 PM |
| Drake |
| Western Ky | 7:05 PM |
| Arkansas State |
| Ark-Little Rock | 7:30 PM |
| Troy |
| Belmont | 7:30 PM |
| Tenn Tech |
| Walla Walla | 8:00 PM |
| Boise State |
| Texas State | 8:00 PM |
| New Mexico St |
| Southern Ill | 8:00 PM |
| Evansville |
| North Dakota | 8:00 PM |
| Weber State |
| Portland State | 8:00 PM |
| Montana |
| Northern Colorado | 8:05 PM |
| Idaho State |
| Idaho | 8:05 PM |
| Utah State |
| NJIT | 8:05 PM |
| Utah Valley U |
| Eastern Wash | 8:05 PM |
| Montana State |
| Washington | 8:30 PM |
| Washington St |
| Portland | 9:00 PM |
| Pepperdine |
| Pacific | 9:00 PM |
| UC Davis |
| UC Irvine | 9:00 PM |
| Cal Poly |
| BYU | 9:00 PM |
| San Francisco |
| CS-Bakersfield | 9:00 PM |
| UNLV |
| Seattle | 9:00 PM |
| San Jose St |
| Cal State Fullerton | 9:05 PM |
| CS-Northridge |
| California | 10:00 PM |
| USC |
| UC Riverside | 10:59 PM |
| Hawaii |
| (5) Oregon | 35 | FINAL |
| (7) Kansas State | 17 |
| (10) Texas A&M | 41 | FINAL |
| (12) Oklahoma | 13 |
| Pittsburgh | 12:00 PM |
| Ole Miss |
| (25) Kent State | 1/6/13 8:00 PM |
| Arkansas State |
| (2) Alabama | 1/7/13 7:30 PM |
| (1) Notre Dame |
| Long Island | 11:00 AM |
| Quinnipiac |
| North Florida | 12:00 PM |
| Stetson |
| Bryant | 12:00 PM |
| St Francis-PA |
| Buffalo | 12:00 PM |
| Cornell |
| Southern Miss | 12:00 PM |
| New Orleans |
| St Francis-NY | 12:00 PM |
| Sacred Heart |
| Presbyterian | 12:00 PM |
| Campbell |
| Fairleigh Dickinson | 12:00 PM |
| Wagner |
| (17) Oklahoma | 12:30 PM |
| Texas |
| Saint Josephs | 1:00 PM |
| Penn |
| Pittsburgh | 1:00 PM |
| Seton Hall |
| Ohio U | 1:00 PM |
| Xavier |
| Brown | 1:00 PM |
| Lafayette |
| Charleston Southern | 1:00 PM |
| Coastal Carolina |
| Lehigh | 1:00 PM |
| NJIT |
| Lamar | 1:00 PM |
| Northwestern St |
| Georgia Southern | 1:00 PM |
| Coll of Charleston |
| Chattanooga | 1:00 PM |
| UNC Greensboro |
| Loyola-Chicago | 1:00 PM |
| Eastern Michigan |
| Wright State | 1:00 PM |
| Memphis |
| (14) Purdue | 1:00 PM |
| (25) Nebraska |
| Maine | 1:00 PM |
| UMBC |
| Georgetown | 1:00 PM |
| Providence |
| Miami-Ohio | 1:00 PM |
| Duquesne |
| Albany | 1:00 PM |
| Binghamton |
| Boston U | 1:00 PM |
| Hartford |
| Wofford | 1:00 PM |
| Western Carolina |
| Samford | 1:30 PM |
| Elon |
| Northern Ill | 1:35 PM |
| Valparaiso |
| New Mexico St | 2:00 PM |
| Texas State |
| Tennessee St | 2:00 PM |
| Jacksonville St |
| Austin Peay | 2:00 PM |
| SE Missouri St |
| Appalachian St | 2:00 PM |
| Davidson |
| St Bonaventure | 2:00 PM |
| Green Bay |
| Central Arkansas | 2:00 PM |
| SE Louisiana |
| UNC-Asheville | 2:00 PM |
| Liberty |
| Weber State | 2:00 PM |
| North Dakota |
| Monmouth | 2:00 PM |
| Mount St Marys |
| IUPU-Ft Wayne | 2:00 PM |
| Nebraska Omaha |
| Oral Roberts | 2:00 PM |
| Nicholls |
| Western Ill | 2:00 PM |
| IUPUI |
| Drake | 2:05 PM |
| Southern Ill |
| Gardner-Webb | 2:30 PM |
| High Point |
| Bucknell | 3:00 PM |
| Yale |
| Central Conn St | 3:00 PM |
| Robert Morris |
| SIU-Edwardsville | 3:00 PM |
| Eastern Kentucky |
| Butler | 3:00 PM |
| Illinois-Chicago |
| (5) Notre Dame | 3:00 PM |
| (1) Connecticut |
| Stony Brook | 3:00 PM |
| New Hampshire |
| San Francisco | 3:00 PM |
| BYU |
| Idaho State | 3:05 PM |
| Northern Colorado |
| Jacksonville | 3:15 PM |
| Fla Gulf Coast |
| USC Upstate | 3:30 PM |
| Northern Ky |
| Montana | 4:00 PM |
| Portland State |
| Murray State | 4:00 PM |
| Tenn-Martin |
| East Tenn St | 4:00 PM |
| Lipscomb |
| TX-Pan American | 4:00 PM |
| Utah Valley U |
| Winthrop | 4:00 PM |
| Longwood |
| Santa Clara | 4:00 PM |
| Gonzaga |
| McNeese State | 4:00 PM |
| Stephen F Austin |
| St Marys-CA | 4:00 PM |
| Loyola Marymount |
| San Diego | 4:00 PM |
| Portland |
| Utah State | 4:00 PM |
| Idaho |
| Montana State | 4:05 PM |
| Eastern Washington |
| Eastern Illinois | 4:15 PM |
| Morehead St |
| Mercer | 4:30 PM |
| Kennesaw St |
| Louisiana | 4:30 PM |
| FIU |
| ULM | 5:00 PM |
| North Texas |
| (11) Louisville | 5:00 PM |
| DePaul |
| Creighton | 5:00 PM |
| Evansville |
| CS-Northridge | 5:00 PM |
| Cal State Fullerton |
| Middle Tennessee | 5:05 PM |
| South Alabama |
| Ark-Little Rock | 5:15 PM |
| Troy |
| Belmont | 5:30 PM |
| Tenn Tech |
| San Jose St | 6:00 PM |
| Seattle |
| TCU | 6:00 PM |
| Kansas State |
| UC Santa Barbara | 6:00 PM |
| Long Beach St |
| CS-Bakersfield | 6:00 PM |
| Nevada |
| Cal Poly | 6:00 PM |
| Cal-Irvine |
| UC Davis | 6:00 PM |
| Pacific |
| Denver | 6:00 PM |
| TX-San Antonio |
| (21) Kansas | 6:30 PM |
| West Virginia |
| Iowa State | 7:00 PM |
| Texas Tech |
| Syracuse | 7:00 PM |
| Marquette |
| TX-Arlington | 7:00 PM |
| Louisiana Tech |
| Hawaii | 7:00 PM |
| UC-Riverside |
| Delaware State | 7:00 PM |
| Houston Baptist |
| UMKC | 7:00 PM |
| No Dakota State |
| Sacramento St | 8:00 PM |
| Southern Utah |
ADVERTISEMENT
inside the StarTribune
-
425 Portland Av. S.
Minneapolis, MN 55488
(612) 673-4000
- Company
- Subscriber Services
- Website
- Buy Ads
- Store
- Connect with Us
© 2013 StarTribune. All rights reserved.
StarTribune.com is powered by Limelight Networks
Newspaper Subscriptions
eEdition
RSS
Newsletters